How is it possible that the F# compiler rejects the type string when it's expecting a System.String?
#I #"..\..\packages"
#r #"FSharp.Data\lib\net40\FSharp.Data.dll"
open FSharp.Data
let [<Literal>] csvFile = #"..\..\data\FootballResults.csv"
type Football = CsvProvider< csvFile >
let data = Football.GetSample().Rows |> Seq.toArray
After running this simple code, I get the error message:
Script.fsx(5,30): error FS0001: This expression was expected to have type 'System.String' but here has type 'string'
I thought string was simply an alias for System.String?
Edit
The csv file is quite big, just the first rows are important:
Date,Home Team,Away Team,Full Time Home Goals,Full Time Away Goals,Full Time Result,Half Time Home Goals,Half Time Away Goals,Half Time Result,Home Shots,Away Shots,Home Shots on Target,Away Shots on Target,Home Fouls,Away Fouls,Home Cards,Away Cards,Home Yellow Cards,Away Yellow Cards,Home Red Cards,Away Red Cards
08/18/2012,Arsenal,Sunderland,0,0,D,0,0,D,14,3,4,2,12,8,7,0,0,0,0,0
08/18/2012,Fulham,Norwich,5,0,H,2,0,H,11,4,9,2,12,11,6,3,0,0,0,0
08/18/2012,Newcastle,Tottenham,2,1,H,0,0,D,6,12,4,6,12,8,3,5,2,2,0,0
The full file can be downloaded here under the folder data
FSharp.Data version
FSharp.Data 2.3.2
I found the problem, it was in the paket script provided in the book Get Programming with F#.
The script was pointing to an old version of FSharp.Data (I thought paket was this amazing package manager that always get you the best version for your project while in fact, it does not, you always fight and struggle with wrong dependencies).
At the end I managed to fix the problem this way:
Solution 1
Simply start a new project using the nuget command Install-Package FSharp.Data -Version 4.2.7 and then the reference to the package #r "nuget: FSharp.Data"
Solution 2
Update the paket.lock provided by the book with the correct version FSharp.Data (4.2.7). The code posted in my question run after that.
Advice for F# learner
Whoever is trying to learn F# with this book, it's a good book but be very careful with their package reference. They seem outdated and can get you into unpleasant situation.
I try to get the Z3 solver up and running in F#. So I created a fresh F# project in Visual Studio, added a reference to Microsoft.Z3.dll, and typed in the following code:
open Microsoft.Z3
let ctx = new Context()
let a = ctx.MkBoolConst("a")
Running this in the interactive window yields the following error:
System.InvalidCastException: Unable to cast object of type 'Microsoft.Z3.AlgebraicNum' to type 'Microsoft.Z3.BoolExpr'.
at Microsoft.Z3.Context.MkBoolConst(String name)
at <StartupCode$FSI_0013>.$FSI_0013.main#() in C:\Users\...\Program.fs:line 3
Stopped due to error
What am I missing?
This sounds very much like https://github.com/Z3Prover/z3/issues/1882
You might have to recompile/reinstall. Follow the instructions in that ticket.
I have 2 files: Asm.fs, AsmTest.fs
Asm.fs
namespace Assembler
[<Measure>] type ln
[<Measure>] type col
[<Measure>] type port
type Addr = int<ln> * int<col> * int<port>
module Asm =
let emptyAddr : Addr = (-1<ln>, -1<col>, -1<port>)
AsmTest.fs
module Assembler.Tests
[<Test>]
let someTest() =
let x = Asm.emptyAddr
When I debug someTest() code, I get that x = null, what am I doing wrong?
P.S. files in the different projects visual studio projects. Asm.fs in the Assembler project and AsmTest.fs in the AssemblerTest project.
I found an interesting behavior. My problem will be resolved, if I add some file (even empty) to the Assembler project. Can anyone explain this behavior?
The debugger sometimes has issues showing the correct values. For me however, having exactly the same Asm.fs and AsmTest.fs like this:
module Assembler.Tests
open NUnit.Framework
[<Test>]
let someTest() =
let x = Asm.emptyAddr
Assert.IsNotNull x
the test passes and if I set a breakpoint at the assertion, x is correctly shown as {(-1, -1, -1)}
As the code that you show does not compile as it is (Block following this let is unfinished. in someTest), could you try my test above and/or show your complete test method?
Using your code I can reproduce the behaviour. If I set my projects to console applications, my test will fail as well. So, it seems that for console projects, not having any other file or an [<EntryPoint>] surprisingly skips the initialization of module values. For me, the compiler at least issues a warning Main module of program is empty where I use x in the test. The solution to the problem is therefore:
make sure you treat warnings as errors
have an [<EntryPoint>] for console applications
use library projects for libraries
I am trying to set up a tiny F# console app with FSharp.Data referenced in the solution. I got the following error at runtime :
An unhandled exception of type 'System.TypeInitializationException' occurred in Anot_F1.exe
for this code (error in line 4) :
1 open FSharp.Data
2 type Anot_lines = CsvProvider<"anot1.csv",Separators=";">
3 let ll = Anot_lines.Load("anot1.csv")
4 for r in ll.Rows do
5 printfn "%A" r.ToString
In debug mode after line 3, I can see that the variable ll contains the proper Headers but does not show the rows.
My CSV file is :
tline;tcol;bline;bcol;anot
3;1;4;16;"Barack Obama has ... The US president"
3;1;3;12;"Barack Obama"
3;18;3;26;"ratcheted"
4;102;4;109;"agencies"
4;289;4;306;"financial pressure"
4;1;4;320;"The US president ...ure on the regime"
4;1;4;16;"The US president"
I am new to F# and especially have no experience on using type providers.
Any help greatly appreciated.
The issue is with line 3, you're using a method that loads CSV data from a URL. You need to use the GetSample() method. Also note that the "%A" format placeholder can print any value and doesn't require a ToString() call.
let ll = Anot_lines.GetSample()
for r in ll.Rows do
printfn "%A" r
I'm trying to use the JsonProvider and I'm getting the following error when I call a function on it:
System.TypeInitializationException was unhandled
Message: An unhandled exception of type 'System.TypeInitializationException' occurred in PortableLibrary1.dll
Additional information: The type initializer for '<StartupCode$PortableLibrary1>.$PortableLibrary1' threw an exception.
I have a basic console application as follows:
module Pinit =
open FSharp.Data
type JsonT = JsonProvider<"""..\myFile.json""">
let doc = JsonT.Load("""..\nyFile.json""")
let result = doc.GeneratedAt
[<EntryPoint>]
let main argv =
printfn "%A" Pinit.doc.GeneratedAt
0
When run within the ConsoleApplication it all works as expected.
If I create an F# Portable Class library as follows:
module Pinit =
open FSharp.Data
type JsonT = JsonProvider<"""..\myFile.json""">
let doc = JsonT.Load("""..\nyFile.json""")
let result = doc.GeneratedAt
Create another Console Application and reference that Portable Class Library and call the code as follows:
open PortableLibrary1
[<EntryPoint>]
let main argv =
printfn "%A" Pinit.result
0
When I run the program then it generates the exception defined above:
I'm suspecting it's because of the versions of FSharp.Core but was wondering whether I was doing something wrong or whether there was a way to get this to work?
Versions:
-- ConsoleApplication --
FSharp.Core = 4.3.1.0
-- PortableClassLibrary --
FSharp.Core = 3.3.1.0
FSharp.Data = NuGet Version: 2.0.0
let bindings are compiled into static members, and in .NET when you have an exception in a static initializer the real exception is masqueraded.
If you turn that into a function call by changing to let result() = doc.GeneratedAt and printfn "%A" (Pinit.result()) you'll get the real exception:
Only web locations are supported
Portable profiles don't support accessing the file system. So inside the PCL you can either have web urls or load manually from an embedded resource. See here for an example: https://github.com/ovatsus/Apps/blob/master/Trains/Stations.fs#L65. Or you can load the file with File.ReadAllText in the console project and pass it to the PCL.
This was with a Portable Profile (Legacy) project, which is Profile 47 (and FSharp.Core 2.3.6.0). I then also tested with a Portable Profile project, which is Profile 7 (and FSharp.Core 3.3), and noticed it's not working correctly, it's giving this exception instead
Method not found: 'FSharp.Data.Runtime.JsonValueOptionAndPath FSharp.Data.Runtime.JsonRuntime.TryGetPropertyUnpackedWithPath(FSharp.Data.Runtime.IJsonDocument, System.String)'.
I created a github issue to track that: https://github.com/fsharp/FSharp.Data/issues/521