First I have did tons of researches on this issue. Non of existing solution similar to my issue.
I developed a framework. It is a pretty heavy framework which include a c++ static library and contains both objective-c and swift codes. I have created a sample app that imports my framework to mimic the behaviour of people can using my framework.
I put the framework under a libs folder of the project. I have make sure the framework is under Embedded Binaries and Linked frameworks and Libraries. I have also make sure that the path to libs folder exists under Framework Search Paths and Library Search Paths and User Header Search Paths.
Now When I run the sample app using my actual device and running on the computer that contain my framework project file, it works perfectly.
However If I run the sample app using simulator devices, it told me No such module x
Moreover If I run the sample app using my actual device and running another computer that I didn't use to develop my framework project, it shows error Cannot load underlying module for x.
Has anyone had this problem before? Any hint would be appreciated.
(I have also tried clean, clean build folder, clean Derived Data, restart Xcode, restart computer etc.)
Solved problem by setting Defines Module to No
Related
I have a specific scenario I am trying to overcome and have yet to find a solution (if one exists) to my problem.
I am building a framework that can be used inside of other applications. This framework contains static libraries.
Now, inside my framework, if I want to add classes that use APIs from Xcode12, I would also want my framework to be able to compile in Xcode11.
This could obviously lead to compilation issues as I have no control of my framework inside other applications and as my framework will already be turned into a binary file (.a). Adding any build script to the frameworks' build phases won't be relevant.
I have been trying to look for similar scenarios or solutions for this problem, but have yet to find anything substantial.
Is there any way to overcome this or am I trying to do something that is impossible?
I am trying to use Berkeley's SPICE tool in an iOS app, but am having trouble compiling it for iOS.
It is a command-line program that I can call from a terminal like:
./spice3f5 <arguments>
Which works well, and I would like this functionality in my iOS app, but I don't think I can just copy the executable over to Xcode and call it from Swift.
I've done some research and found the following:
There is an updated version of SPICE called ngspice, which is relatively new (2014 release)
I'm fairly sure there are apps out there than have used either SPICE or ngspice, so I'm sure it can be done somehow.
I have read an article about a guy who says that ngspice has been compiled as a shared library(ctrl+f "ngspice"), and he made an app with it. I have emailed him but he unfortunately he has not responded.
The reason I am asking here is because when googling for "ngspice iOS", I came across this thread which has a lot of smart people trying to compile a static library, which seems way out of my scope. I learned that dynamic libraries are allowed as of iOS8. So would it be easier to compile a *.dylib than it is a static library?
How would I goabout using ngspice or SPICE in an iOS app?
Thanks
The difference between a static and a dynamic library is essentially where they live, a static library will live inside the binary of your app, and an dynamic library will live on the system (iPhone) that runs your app. there isn't much difference as far as difficulty goes. If you wanted to go the dynamic route on os x for example, you might compile a .dylib file in a separate project first. Then copy your new .dylib file into /usr/lib or a similar location that is part of your system's path. Then you would need to copy the associated header files that know how to talk to your new .dylib file into your /usr/include folder. At this point you could import said header files in xcode using angle brackets like so:
#import <my_dylib_header_file.h>
in static world however, you would simply drag your .dylib file into xcode then copy the associated header files into your source folder and then import using quotes like so:
#import "my_dylib_header_file.h"
the advantage of doing the import statically is that the library becomes baked into your final product, as opposed to a dynamic link, which will require that the dylib is installed on the system prior to the binary being able to run properly (think DLL's on windows). The disadvantage of a static import is that the final binary is larger, as it contains more code.
The advantage of a dynamic import is that the binary is smaller, and dylib can be updated without updating the binary itself.
However based on your questions I don't think any of this matters for your project. You have the source code. Which means creating a dylib is entirely unnecessary for your purpose, you can treat the source code like a static library by simply adding it to your xcode project. If I were you I would add the spice source code to my xcode project and forget about creating a dylib. From there I would import the files and make calls to them from swift. There are lots of threads out there that explain how call c functions or objective-c classes from swift so I wont go into that here, instead I'll refer you to another answer: Swift: How to call a C function loaded from a dylib
I know of familiar tutorials on this, but introduction of framework XCode 6 template has changed the game.
I already watched WWDC 2014 video about building modern frameworks but it talks more about building extensions, framework & app all inside single project. It does not specify if the framework I make with it is truly reusable across any project.
I am building framework the XCode 6 way (File->New Project->Framework and Library->Cocoa Touch Framework), but when I import it inside my test app project (separate from framework project) - I keep getting various errors.
Example: Include of non-modular header inside framework, and so on.
I know this is not what it says, and there are quite some missing steps in whatever I am doing. The older tricks may have worked for everyone, but I simply don't find which way to follow after XCode 6.
For example, there is some folder structure that a framework needs, but XCode 6 doesn't comply to it while building it. Is it right? If not, how can I change the way the XCode builds framework folder hierarchy?
Do I go back to old school or am I screwing some tiny thing in XCode 6 that I am unable to create a reusable framework?
I am not sure if you are trying to build a framework with Objective-C or Swift as your question doesn't state it. I've encountered errors you are mentioning with Swift so I'll give you my method to build Swift frameworks.
I found the process for Objective-C to be very straightforward and well documented, so I'll skip this.
As for Swift, there are a few things to consider. First, Swift static libraries are not supported, so you must exclusively use a framework (aka dynamic library) when linking an app to a library.
Here are the steps:
Create the Framework using New > Project under IOS > Framework & Library, select Cocoa Touch Framework
To avoid the "ld: warning: directory not found for option..." goto Library Search Paths in Build Settings for your target and delete the paths.
You can't mix Objective-C with Swift so don't even consider adding the Swift-Header bridge file in your code.
There are some cases in swift where you need to import code from unexposed Frameworks. I've successfully used the module-map inside the framework to deal with these case.
I also select CLANG_ALLOW_NON_MODULAR_INCLUDES_IN_FRAMEWORK_MODULES = YES in the Build Settings to solve 'include of non-modular header inside framework module'. That seems to work
I make sure that the header file that gets generated is marked as Public (not Project). Click on the file and you'll see the selection in the inspector under 'Target Membership'
You may run into some bizarre error messages when building. Xcode has a tendency to report linker errors when your code can't compile correctly resulting in missing files the linker needs to output its binaries. Sometimes XCode won't show the errors in the files you are compiling and you need to go manually on the build output and go back to the files. Some other time, you'll get a problem where you need to delete the cache. Those issues I call XCode blues and deal with it constantly. I found this type of problems happens more often when building libraries. The rest should work as expected.
I have a C library whose code resides in say /repos1/clib. I build that from the command line using the latest iOS sdk to create clib.a (including a debug build for the simulator) which I copy to an iOS project say in /repos2/proj.
I have been using this setup for several years. The old C library very occasionally might require some debugging and I was pleased by the fact that Xcode simply stepped into the library code that was outside the project (inside repos1) without having to do any setup - it just worked.
But this was up until a few Xcode versions ago. I am not sure exactly when it changed - perhaps when they moved from gcc to llvm? - since I very seldom needed to debug the C code, but for a while now I only get dissasembly when I try to debug the C library from the iOS project (including at least references to the C file name & line number). For the few times I need to debug it is very inconvenient (I create a temp project that includes the C code).
So, any idea why it worked before and doesn't now? Where should I look? Could it be the way I build the C library, maybe there was a flag in gcc I was using that does not have an equivalent in llvm (I can find and post the old build command I was using if it is relevant)? Is the issue in Xcode and there is a way to tell it where to look for the sources?
Thanks!
Edit: To make it clear, I can add the C library either as the source or as a subproject in Xcode, however for reasons that are out of scope this is not helpful for this specific project. So, can it work like it used to with older Xcode versions? If not, it would still be interesting to know why not.
The recommended approach is to create a library project in Xcode, one for iOS (there is a template for it), then when you get that to build add that project to your app, make sure the lib is a dependency and gets linked. There are many tutorials on the web how to do this.
Then as iOS evolves and new architectures (armv7s) arrive you simply update both projects.
I was struggling with the same issue.
I tried resetting in library/application project all options related to symbol stripping and copy application project to same truecrypt drive as library project but it didn't help.
In my case it appeared it was an app project issue. Same library could be debugged in another app project with source code so that was a clue.
I had more than one version of the same library in app project and set only target membership to choose which should be used. Not sure if that could affect my app project somehow.
Nevertheless after deleting all libraries and copying them to app project again I was able to debug libraries with access to source code.
I am currently building a library which should be used internally in a few iOS projects but should also be distributed to customers accessing our services with the library. The Library itself consists purely of C++ code and I am basically able to create Apps with it on iOS which work fine. My problem is creating a single, easily distributable file that can be given out to customers which can easily install them, use the provided headers and don't need to have the headaches that I am currently facing when it comes to linking.
Our code depends on two other projects, namely boost and websocketpp. For boost there is the script on github which I took to generate a framework. For websocketpp, I imported it into XCode and used the scripts from this github project to build a framework. I added both frameworks to my (potential) framework as dependencies and used the same script to build one.
I have an app using my library as a sub-project working fine. Even including the framework into the project and running it on a device works fine. So far so good.
However, trying to create an archive of the App project lead to several questions and headaches.
My library did not seem to contain the code for all architectures. So I tried to archive the Framework projects, which after small modifications in the build scripts to use different locations to search for headers worked fine.
It does not seem to contain all binary code or references to local files (i.e. my specific location of boost). I gathered that from Linker errors that I still get that tell me that some boost calls could not be satisfied.
The second issue made me think that I am must be doing something fundamentally wrong and my intuition tells me that it can't be that difficult and "hackish" to create frameworks or libraries for others for iOS development.
As you probably have found out by now, I am not very experienced when it comes to iOS and I am wondering if I am missing something fundamentally. So, I am sure that this question is rather broad, so some more concrete questsions:
Is there a(nother) way to generate some kind of distributable (preferably a framework) which contains: my public headers, my binary code compiled for all platforms supported for iOS development, the binary code of dependencies?
Is the only way to do that by adding some handwritten scripts to the build process?
I have the feeling that the information I found is quite outdated since it's older than a year and mostly refers to Xcode 4.2 or 4.3 -- so has there anything changed in this regard recently?
For example one error I get is:
File is universal (2 slices) but does not contain a(n) armv7s slice: <file>
The <file> slice is the path to the file in the framework in the Products folder of a different XCode workspace (the library was build in a different workspace then the app). I dropped the framework folder into the project for this test from a completely different location.
What is going on here?
Why does it keep referencing to some internal XCode directory?
How do I properly export it?
Since I guess my setup is probably skrewed up and weird from all the different things I tried up to now: How does this setup look like in a ideal situation?
Yes, there are some questions regarding this on SO already, however, either I don't see or don't understand in those replies:
...how to handle depencies of my code to other third-party code properly.
...how to generate a distributable file.
Have you checked your project build phase under Compile Sources and Copy Files to see if you are including your framework source files in your build?
You may also try the C/C++ Library template under OSX -> Framework & Library.
Finally, there's also kstenerud’s iOS Universal Framework, which I found very useful. I wrote a few articles in my blog on using it.