On a Mac, Docker has a built in kubernetes mode that helps you set up a dev cluster in 1 click. Is there a way to do with with Docker-CE on my linux laptop? If not, what is the recommended approach (seems weird that this is actually easier on a mac or windows lol)
To get the current OS version, try kubectl get nodes -o wide
If you're looking to run a local Kubernetes cluster, you should use Minikube: https://kubernetes.io/docs/getting-started-guides/minikube/
Related
When I run my docker container using Docker Desktop for Windows I am able to connect to it using
docker run -p 5051:5000 my_app
http://0.0.0.0:5051
However when I open another terminal and do this
minikube docker-env | Invoke-Expression
and build and run the same container using the same run command as above
I cannot connect to the running instance.
Should I be running and testing the containers using Docker Desktop, then using minikube to store the images only (for Kubernetes)? Or can you run them and test them as well through minikube?
That's because on your second attempt, the container is not running on the host but on the minikube VM. You'll be able to access it using the minikube VM IP.
To get the minikube ip you can run minikube ip
Why ?
Invoking minikube docker-env sets all the docker env variable on your host to match the minikube environment. This means that when you run a container after that, it is run with the docker daemon on the minikube VM.
I asked you if there are any specific reasons to use Docker Desktop and Minikube together on a single machine as these are two competitive solutions which basically enable you to perform similar tasks and achieve same goals.
This article nicely explains differences between these two tools.
Docker-for-windows uses Type-1 hypervisor, such as Hyper-V, which are
better compared to Type-2 hypervisors, such as VirtualBox, while
Minikube supports both hypervisors. Unfortunately, there are a couple
of limitations in which technology you are using, since you cannot
have Type-1 or Type-2 hypervisors running at the same time on your
machine
If you use Docker Desktop and Minikube at the same time I assume you're using Type-1 hypervisor, such as mentioned Hyper-V, but keep in mind that even if they use the same hypervisor, both tools create their own instances of virtual machine. Basically you are not supposed to use those two tools together expecting that they will work as a kind of hybrid that lets you manage single container environment.
First check what hypervisor you are using exactly. If you're using Hyper-V, simple Get-VM command in Powershell (more details in this article) should tell you what you currently have.
#mario no, I didn't know minikube had a docker daemon until recently
which is why I have both
Yes, Minikube has built in docker environment (in fact it sets everything up, but yes, it also sets up container runtime) so basically you don't need to install docker additionally, and as #Marc ABOUCHACRA already suggested in his answer, Minikube runs the whole environment (single node k8s cluster with docker runtime) on a separate VM. Linux version has an option --vm-driver=none which allows you to use your host container runtime and set-up k8s components on it, but this is not the case with Windows version - here you can only use one of two currently supported hypervisors: Hyper-V or VirtualBox (ref).
I wouldn't say that Docker Destkop runs everything on your host. It also uses Type-1 hypervisor to run the container runtime environment. Please check the Get-VM command on your computer and it should be clear what VMs you have and created by which tool.
If I run a minikube instance on ubuntu do I need a VM like virtualbox?
If I run minikube start it complains that I need to install a VM, seems weird to have to do that on linux tho.
While it is possible to run without a VM via --vm-driver=none it really isn't recommended outside of ephemeral CI instances. Minikube expects to be able to take over the system pretty fully to do its thang. I would recommend checking out one of the other tools to manage a local environment like microk8s (available as a Snap too), Kind, or possibly k3s.
Just use microk8s instead
https://tutorials.ubuntu.com/tutorial/install-a-local-kubernetes-with-microk8s#4
that's what you need
I want to use minikube on Windows 10. I have installed VirtualBox and want to use it as the virtual machine for minikube. Also I installed Docker for windows. But during installation Docker forced to use Hyper-V as default. But that means I can no longer use VirtualBox to run minikube! Not sure what am I missing here.
I have used minikube on Mac and there it was much simpler: simply open VirtualBox and then run command on command line: minikube start . However in Windows 10 it seems much more complicated.
Just to make things clear: Docker requires Hyper-V to be turned on, and Virtualbox requires Hyper-V to be turned off. The reason is they use different virtualization technologies, to be exact - type 1 and type 2 hypervisors:
Type 1 hypervisor: hypervisors run directly on the system hardware – A
“bare metal” embedded hypervisor, Type 2 hypervisor: hypervisors run
on a host operating system that provides virtualization services, such
as I/O device support and memory management.
I've found that there are few approaches to this issue. One of them is adding another boot option and rebooting every time you needed to switch between hypervisors, but it seems that this method is as good as manually turning off Hyper-V, restarting and then using your minikube in VirtualBox. This is probably not the desired state.
So as you can't use them at once, you will have to use a tool that was introduced by Docker for older Windows systems. This is because Docker Toolbox is not using Hyper-V.
Please treat this solution as a workaround, and even Docker does not recommend using Docker toolbox if you can use Docker. Also, you could achieve the same results with minikube running on Hyper-V.
0) Uninstall Docker, turn off Hyper-V, delete all traces of minikube, uninstall VirtualBox (if you tried to run it previously.)
1) Install [Docker Toolbox] - choose full installation2
2) Install Virtualbox, run docker run hello-world inside of Docker Quickstart Terminal and verify if everything is working correctly.
3) Install minikube for Windows (I used chocolatey)
4) Run minikube start.
I've tested this steps, and I was able to run Docker containers in the Docker toolbox in the meantime initializing a Kubernetes cluster in minikube.
Most tutorials I've seen for developing with Kubernetes locally use Minikube. In the latest Edge release of Docker for Windows, you can also enable Kubernetes. I'm trying to understand the differences between the two and which I should use.
Minikube lets you choose the version of Kubernetes you want, can Docker for Windows do that? I don't see a way to configure it.
Minikube has CLI commands to enable the dashboard, heapster, ingress and other addons. I'm not sure why because my undertstanding is that these are simply executing kubectl apply -f http://....
With Minikube I can do a minikube ip to get the cluster IP address for ingress, how can I do this with Docker for Windows?
Is there anything else different that I should care about.
I feel like you largely understand the space, and mostly have answers to your questions already. You might find Docker for Mac vs. Docker Toolbox an informative read, even if it's about the Mac equivalent rather than Windows and about Docker packaged as a VM rather than Kubernetes specifically.
In fact you are stuck with the specific version of Kubernetes the Docker Edge desktop distribution publishes.
is answered in the question.
I believe NodePort-type Services are published on your host's IP address; there isn't an intermediate VM address like there is with Docker Toolbox.
Docker Toolbox and minikube always use a full-blown virtual machine with an off-the-shelf hypervisor. The Docker desktop application might use a lighter-weight virtualization engine if one is available.
Kubernetes can involve some significant background work. If you're using Kubernetes-in-Docker it's hard to "turn off" Kubernetes and still have Docker available; but if you have a separate minikube VM you can just stop it.
Here is a part from Docker documentation:
Kubernetes is only available in Docker for Windows 18.02 CE Edge.
Kubernetes support is not included in Docker for Windows 18.02 CE
Stable. To find out more about Stable and Edge channels and how to
switch between them, see General configuration.
Docker for Windows 18.02 CE Edge includes a standalone Kubernetes
server and client, as well as Docker CLI integration. The Kubernetes
server runs locally within your Docker instance, is not configurable,
and is a single-node cluster.
The Kubernetes server runs within a Docker container on your local
system, and is only for local testing. When Kubernetes support is
enabled, you can deploy your workloads, in parallel, on Kubernetes,
Swarm, and as standalone containers. Enabling or disabling the
Kubernetes server does not affect your other workloads.
See Docker for Windows > Getting started to enable Kubernetes and
begin testing the deployment of your workloads on Kubernetes.
If you have enough CPU and RAM resources, you can easily have both, minikube and docker-for-desktop on the same machine and switch between them by selecting the context, e.g.:
> kubectl config get-contexts
> kubectl config use-context docker-for-desktop
There is no place at the moment to choose the Kubernetes version for docker-for-desktop. It is preselected in the Docker distribution package.
Unfortunately, version of docker inside the minikube is a step behind compared to available on the docker website, and some features could be missing, but if you are interested in Kubernetes environment, it doesn't really matter in most cases.
Some of the features of Kubernetes rely on external resources and could be unavailable for you in case of local installation. For example, you need an ability to create Cloud Load Balancer to use some types of the Ingress or Service objects.
But other resources can be easily started inside the minikube, or docker-for-desktop using kubectl create/apply.
To expose your cluster resources externally, you can use Webhook Relay Ingress controller.
Here is a link to the installation manual.
I've read that:
Docker is a system for management and deployment of application containers, not operating system containers.
However, in several resources (e.g. around 1:20 into https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGYAg7TMmp0) it gives an example of "problems" you might encounter if you've developed a web application on a Windows PC or Mac, and are deploying it to a Linux server.
So, how does Docker help in this situation? If we take a web application I understand Docker could help you make a container with the source, and say a specific version of PHP. But could you specify a target OS for it to run on, if it's different from the server that Docker is running on?
The Docker FAQ (https://docs.docker.com/engine/faq/) says
You can run both Linux and Windows programs and excutables in Docker containers.
Does this mean you need Docker installed on a Linux and Windows machine separately to do this, or is it possible to specify any OS within your Docker image and have any machine run it?
Please can someone explain how - or if - Docker deals with specifying a particular OS for your application?
Docker started as a way to run containers on Linux hosts, and this remains the dominate target for docker containers. Developer environments include an embedded VM to run Linux under the covers on Mac and Windows. Originally this was VirtualBox, but newer releases use xhyve and hyperv. The host OS in all of these are Linux so you are not building your image on one OS and running it on another OS.
Since that start, Docker has expanded target OS's. This requires that you have a docker installation for that OS, and it requires that your image be designed to run on that architecture/OS. This started with other architectures of Linux like arm64, and now zLinux. The Microsoft partnership is a rather large rewrite, partially in Windows itself, but also in the Docker code, and especially in the images designed to run natively on Windows. To run these, you have to change the settings on Docker for Windows to run Windows containers instead of Linux containers, you cannot run them both concurrently on the same host. At present, running Windows binaries can only be done on a Windows host, Microsoft isn't shipping free VMs for Linux hosts. And as a new target platform, it still lags behind in features from the Linux hosts.