Well, my collectionView:didSelectItemAtIndexPath: not being called.
I've read a lot answers, none helped me.
There is no view that takes the touch and prevents tap (I've doubled check)
So I started to explore:
The collection view has 3 GestureRecognizers:
UIScrollViewDelayedTouchesBeganGestureRecognizer
UIScrollViewPanGestureRecognizer
_UIDragAutoScrollGestureRecognizer
As you can see, none of them is a UITapGestureRecognizer
According to the docs:
The collection view calls this method when the user successfully selects an item in the collection view. It does not call this method when you programmatically set the selection.
Well, should I add a TapGesture recognizer myself? And call the delegate methods? I don't think so. Apple done something, but that something is not working!
Well I got it figured out and I'm sure it will help others. Thanks for all who tried to help - you helped because I thought it's not suppose to work and you gave me the reason to keep try =]
Well I had the following hierarchy:
View
|
+----CollectionView
|
+----CollectionViewCell
|
+----TextView
The TextView fills the whole cell.
The problem was that the TextView blocks every tap and not forwards it to the cell!!
But it DOES forward other touches (like Pan)
The solution is:
cell.textView.isUserInteractionEnabled = false
Related
Edit: I am editing my initial question (see below for history) as I am getting new information.
I figured out that when the swipe motion starts from inside the button bounds, we never receive TouchesEnded or TouchesCancelled, only TouchesMoved. However, if I can react on WillEnddragging, it would be great. Is it possible to cancel a gesture on WillEndDragging and also pass this cancel down the children chain?
History:
I am using Xamarin Forms and I have the following issue
I have custom controls part of native scrolling views, like ScrollView or CollectionView, that remain in "clicked" state after the finger enters them but then initiates a scroll gesture.
I had a similar issue on UWP in the past and managed to solve it with the UIElement.PointerCaptureLost event.
Sorry if I am wasting your time on trivial stuff, but I am really stuck and I greatly appreciate your help.
I have tried different approaches suggested, including setting DelaysContentTouches to NO, and playing around with CanCancelContentTouches and overriding TouchesShouldCancelInContentView to always return NO, in a ScrollView custom renderer.
I have had a read of
Allow UIScrollView and its subviews to both respond to a touch
and
UIScrollView sending touches to subviews
Maybe the accepted answer here helps, but I am not sure how to get the tag of my custom view.
What I am expecting is my custom controls to receive the cancelled touch event (or something similar) as happens in both Android and Windows
This was easier than it looked. Solved by adding a UIGestureRecognizerDelegate to my UIGestureRecognizer class and in the delegate I overwrote ShouldRecognizeSimultaneously to return true.
I have a super view that has a UITapGestureRecognizer on it. It allows touches within the view because there are clickable items within the view.
When these items are clicked on, I want to take a specific action, not the generic one that covers the entire superview. Unfortunately in my TouchDown event of my child control I don't know how to stop the event here. I know I could create a kludge flag, but this seems like the wrong way to go.
Any advice?
James
OK I got a solution. Totally my problem. I was playing around with trying to get all touches to work and at one point I had set cancelTouchesInView = true on the UITapGestureRecognizer superview. While this didn't stop the other touches from happening, for whatever reason the touches carried through to the superview as well. I understand that this explanation probably makes no sense, but that's what did it. Still trying to wrap my head around how iOS does touch.
I have a custom class here that consists of a UIButton inside of a UIView.
The goal of this class is to allow users to have a greater area (being the UIView) to select the button than just the buttons frame itself.
Now when a user taps on the view I want the buttons highlighted image to show... But the problem is, it does not.
I've read many possible solutions to this issue For Example:
Calling: [btnObject sendActionsForControlEvents:UIControlEventTouchUpInside]
This however did not change the buttons highlight.
I also tried just settings the button.highlighted = YES;
But that did not work either.
I have the images for different states properly setup (Normal and Highlighted), I'm sure of that.
I also have the gestureRecognizer working properly as the functionality is great except for the lack of highlight.
Does anybody know if I'm missing any thing special that needs to be done in order to pull off this seemingly very simple task? Surely it's been done many times.
Thank you
You were on the right track. -[UIButton setHighlighted:] is just a flag. What you need to do is call setNeedsDisplay on that button right after you change the highlighted property.
I solved my problem a little while ago and I'm not sure if Kevin Low's answer would've worked too, it very well might have.
But for some reason, a UITapGesture doesn't work well with highlighting buttons as a view transitions (That might be because I didn't call setNeedsDisplay). The gesture that ended up working was the UILongPressGesture with a 0.0 sec for minimum duration.
So I have added a UIUITableView to a UIViewController. I can't use a UITableViewController for reasons I don't need to explain since it will be unnecessary information. Anyway, I have set the delegate, and the data source to this viewController. I've added the delegate and datasource protocols as well. The cells are populated correctly, so the datasource is working fine. I can also scroll so it all works fine.
However, I can't get the didSelectRowAtIndexPath to trigger. It SHOULD trigger, but doesn't. I've read and a lot of issues with this can be correlated to a UIGestureRecognizer, but I haven't implemented one. I also use the standard UITableView, so not a custom made one.
If I long press the cells (3-4 sec) then it gets triggered as it's supposed to. This suggests that there is some issue with another view or something absorbing the tap gesture, which I have no control over. How would I solve this?
No, it's not didDeselectRowAtIndexPath.
Yes all delegates and datasources are correct, since I can get the delegates/sources to trigger.
Yes, Single Selection is set on the TableView in the inspector.
Yes, everything has user interaction enabled.
If I just copy the code over to a UITableViewController it will work just fine, but right now that is not an option, I'm afraid. Anyone got any ideas on how to solve this? Most people who've had this issue has either had the issues in the list above, or added a UIGesture on top of the UITableView - I haven't.
I want to start by saying that I appreciate all the answers here provided, it gave me a lot of things to try out so I learned a lot - thanks! None of your suggestions worked, but simply because I'm a complete idiot. I said in the post that I did NOT implement a UIGestureRecognizerwhich I didn't...in that class, but in its super class. So I DID in fact implement it, but in a class that this ViewController was a subclass off. The only reason I didn't remember it was because I haven't looked at that super class for weeks.
Someone did suggest it in the comments that I should check for it, and I did and I was already certain I didn't implement one, so I quickly dismissed it. But now, after about 4 hours of debugging and recreating the project, adding things one by one, I eventually realized that the only thing that differed at this point was the Super Class, and the first piece of code I see when I open the file up was a GestureRecognizer...
So keep this in mind in the future everyone - I know I will. Thanks again for the help!
Sincerely,
The complete idiot.
Make sure you don't add any controller in that cell, which covers the entire cell and also the user interaction of that controller is enabled.
Due to that controller's user interaction enabled the tap action is taken by that controller and when you long press that cell, that cell will receive your tap.
Example :
UIView *_view = [[UIView alloc] initWithFrame:CGRectMake(0, 0, _cellWidth, _cellHeight)];
[_view setUserInteractionEnabled:YES];
[cell.contentView addSubview:_view];
In the above case that view got your tap instated of the cell.
I have spent countless hours trying to get SWTableViewCell working, and I've run out of ideas. I'm trying to integrate it into a UITableViewController that contains a custom UITableViewCell (subclassed). For some reason, I can't get any of the animation working. I thought at first that MMDrawerController might have been causing the problem, but after completely removing it's usage, the swipe still doesn't produce animation. So that's not the culprit.
I've gone so far as to try a different cell swipe implementation (TLSwipeForOptionsCell), but I get the same results of no action. I've also tried MCSwipeTableViewCell, which does work in showing the swipe action, but unfortunately presents it's own problems since it doesn't support auto-layout.
For the SWTableViewCell, I can confirm by stepping through the code that
The class receives the gesture and steps through the logic of the code appropriately.
The delegate methods are getting fired appropriately, so the control should have done what it was supposed to do.
However, nothing happens in my table view cell. No animation, no glitch/flicker, no sign that anything has changed.
I've also followed the guidance for using table view editing, which did remove the default "delete" option (desired to remove that anyway), but it still doesn't work.
As you can see in the documentation on GitHub, integrating this should be super simple, but it just doesn't work for me.
Target is iOS 7.1 SDK.
For SWTableViewCell (the swipe implementation I'd prefer to use), I've just noticed that the selection of the cell is lost almost immediately when starting to drag. If I touch and hold on the cell, it is selected. I move just slightly, and selection is lost. However, with MCSwipeTableViewCell the selection is not lost.
Any ideas?
At the expense of looking like an idiot, I'm going to log what the problem was just in case someone else makes the same mistake.
In addition to the symptoms above, I was also having a problem where touching on the cell so that the selection state was triggered would result in a highlight that covered all of my controls--the cell looked empty/blank. That was also resolved with the solution below.
In Interface Builder, I had set the backgroundView Outlet to contentView. Don't do that. Bad stuff happens.
Hope someone else ends up benefiting from this.