I am writing a .Net Core 2.0 MVC-like app where users log in and then do such operations on an AAD B2C tenant such as add new user, edit user, delete user etc.
Listing and adding users was pretty easy to do, but now when I try to remove certain users, I get a 403 Forbidden error. I'm assuming it's because I missed permissions somewhere, but I don't really know where.
I have enabled literally ALL possible App permissions in my AAD B2C Tenant b2c-extensions-app and most of the ones that sound right (30 app+30 delegated) in apps.dev.microsoft.com. I added the account I log in to test to owner list, too. Any clues on why I keep getting those errors would be much appreciated. What are the things I could have missed?
// I found out that to delete users, Directory.AccessAsUser.All is required. I already have it in delegated permissions but I keep getting the same error.
// Yes, I did add myself as owner to b2c-extensions-app and I also added literally every possible permission to it. Windows Azure Active Directory has 7+9, Microsoft Graph has 37+78.
// Okay it seems that the same error occurs when I try to edit a user's password (or any contents, really), too.
Did you setup your permissions through Azure portal or PowerShell?
Delete permissions for a B2C application must be created using PowerShell.
You can find instructions on this page of Microsoft Docs, under the section 'Configure delete permissions for your application'.
Let me know if it helped!
Related
I tried to receive all events for an Microsoft 365 User. It's a business license and a add an App with all User/Mail/Calendar Permissions (also consent granted) to Api permissions.
When running this command or some similar like in the documentation I got 403
Client error: `GET https://graph.microsoft.com/v1.0/users/xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx/events` resulted in a `403 Forbidden` re
sponse:
{"error":{"code":"ErrorAccessDenied","message":"Access is denied. Check credentials and try again."}}
What did I do wrong? I also tried the Graph Explorer (with logged in user).
Are the permissions you are assigning delegated or application permissions?
If you are using application permissions for your App Registration then you need to give access on the user's calendar to the app (probably by using a new service principal on exchange online).
If you are using delegated permissions then you should check the access token you are getting for validation in jwt.ms
Bear in mind that Graph explorer with logged in user needs different permissions than your App Registration. ( it's a different app registration altogether )
Seems like I had the same issue https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/answers/questions/1165285/microsoft-graph-get-outlook-calendar-events-403?page=1&orderby=Helpful&comment=answer-1168253#newest-answer-comment
The fix was to remove all the other permissions and just give it
I'm currently trying implement an app to read calendars only for a group that's permitted to the app. The idea behind this is that when I want to add a another calendar all I'd have to do is add the object to a specific o365 group. I'm taking the application approach over delegation that way I don't have anything actually logging in to utilize the app. Ultimately I'd like to stay away from any of the *.All permissions for security reasons.
Steps taken :
- created o365 group
- added resource objects and one user service account (just for testing) to the group
- registered app
- generated secret
- assigned group to the app
- granted admin consent to groups.selected via the azure portal
When I run a GET for group/{id}/members :
{'error': {'code': 'Authorization_RequestDenied', 'message': 'Insufficient privileges to complete the operation.', 'innerError': {'request-id': '473410a8-4db4-49d6-8d2c-92b9fbd4edb1', 'date': '2020-03-05T14:59:28'}}}
As per the docs
https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/graph/api/group-list-members?view=graph-rest-1.0&tabs=http
If you are using Application permissions to Get Members for a group. you will need User.Read.All, Group.Read.All, Directory.Read.All.
The usual issue is not granting that permissions to the application in Portal.azure.com and admin consenting it.
If you're confident with that. Then I'd eliminate your code as being the issue by using something like postman with your app id and client secret. We have a sample Postman collection here https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/graph/use-postman . for delegated permissions you can use our Graph Explorer playground.
MS docs says:
Note: This permission is exposed in the Azure portal for a feature that is not available for general use. Do not use this permission as it is subject to change.
https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/graph/permissions-reference
I also would like reset a user password using Microsoft Graph from a windows service using admin permissions. Using PATCH request to the user's profile
seemed promising but the required Directory.AccessAsUser.All permission is not on the list at apps.dev.microsoft.com so I get a "Insufficient privileges to complete the operation." error.
I had promised to replace PowerShell cmdlets with Microsoft Graph in our application and this small but essential feature now becomes a blocker.
Is there a plan to add this permission to the list?
Is there any way I can assign this permission? perhaps by editing the manifest? If so does anyone know the correct info
"resourceAppId": "????",
"resourceAccess": [
{
"id": "????",
"type": "Scope"
,
What's with the office portal Azure Directory Admin, app registration (preview)? I can see the app I registered at apps.dev.microsoft.com. Is it now an alternative to apps.dev? I like the interface better and the built-in admin consent button.
There is no application permission (yet) that allows you to reset a user's password using Microsoft Graph.
Is there a plan to add this permission to the list?
Yes, but that's about all there is to share, at the moment.
Is there any way I can assign this permission?
The only way to achieve this today (2019-01-17) is to assign the "Company Administrator" role to the ServicePrincipal object for your app — a very risky move (which is not recommended), as it will give your app full admin permissions.
What's with the office portal Azure Directory Admin, app registration (preview)? [...] Is it now an alternative to apps.dev?
Yes, though it's still in preview and it's possible some things might not work (as with all things in preview).
I'm wondering if we just found a bug in the MS Graph API. I'm trying to access a different user's inbox mail rules via MS Graph. Here's what I did:
1.) Registered an application on the V1 Azure AD Endpoint, with ALL delegated permissions (including MailBoxSettings.Read and MailBoxSettings.ReadWrite)
2.) Granted access to the application using a global admin account
3.) Got a Graph Bearer Token for the tenant & proper permissions:
4.) Delegated mailbox access (full access) to my Global Admin account in Exchange Online settings:
5.) Verified that I have access to the users inbox via Graph:
6.) Attempting to list messagerules for this user fails:
Note that retrieving the current (global admin) user's mail rules works without an issue:
GET /https://graph.microsoft.com/v1.0/me/mailfolders/inbox/messageRules
This tells me that there is probably a bug in MS Graph - or am I maybe missing something?
Thanks in advance
Ben
I have tried this, and I have get the same error. As my understand, we can not get the other's email rules. If you want to use this case, we can submit this issue on the github Issue
To read other users emaill inbox you need Application Type permission set rather than Delegated access.
Follow this link
https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/graph/auth-v2-service
I have registered my application here.
I have given all permissions to my App in that panel as well.
I specifically need Groups.ReadWrite.All which requires an admin ? requirement I am not sure what this even means.
https://apps.dev.microsoft.com/#/application/
Okay App is registered and redirect url has been copied.
Now I take that redirect url copy it and paste it into the admin panel for apps. At this link at App Registrations
https://portal.azure.com/
I am not sure why I have to register in two different panels, one which gives me a redirect url for my native app and the other that leaves it blank.
Great So then I setup my iOS app to make a graph request. This scope
https://graph.microsoft.com/Calendars.ReadWrite
I need to readwrite groups so I add this permission
https://graph.microsoft.com/Group.ReadWrite.All
It fails to authenticate.
I have checked that I have added the permissions to my app, and I have at this app registration panel https://apps.dev.microsoft.com/#/application/
Then I try to add the same permissions in the
https://portal.azure.com/
it gives me
Unable to Complete Request Validation Error, then doesn't do anything.
I tried to add a non admin permission same error.
So what is going on here ... ?
So even though they told me use the Graph API from now on moving forward in the docs I tried to go back to their office 365 SDK for iOS, it also has problems as I cannot get the pods to work as per instructions.
I am 100% sure after this issue is resolved I will need permissions
Note: I work at as a consultant for a bank so if someone can tell me what the azure administrator at the bank has to do to get my permissions escalated to admin status that would be great....
Thanks
Those are 2 different registrations,
Per this documentation (https://graph.microsoft.io/en-us/docs/authorization/auth_overview), for personal accounts like live.com or outlook.com, use the Azure AD v2.0, and for the enterprise, use the Azure AD.
So, for your case, I believe you need the latter, the azure AD.
For this to happen, as you said, go https://portal.azure.com/ and add the app registration.
In order to do so, you would need to
select "Azure Active Directory" and go "App registrations".
Once you create an app, you would need to select "native" for the iOS, and then under app access, under "required permissions" add "Microsoft Graph" followed by selected permissions you would like.
To answer the note, you would need permissions to create an app at the portal, otherwise, you would need to ask for that permission or have the admin create an app for you.
Some samples are available at https://github.com/microsoftgraph/ios-objectivec-connect-sample and https://github.com/microsoftgraph/ios-swift-connect-sample for iOS samples.
Hope this helps!