quoting troubles in Lua - lua

Question

I am trying to make a quote function in lua, so i can use the arguments as strings but without quotes or access them in some environment. Much like in the second comment on this question
w = print
function test()
local function _ix( _ , k )
w( " _ix \\ " , _ , k )
local v = rawget( _G , k )
w( " <-- " , k )
return k
end
local _ = setmetatable( {} , { __index = _ix } )
local function q( _ ) return _ end
q = setfenv( q , _ )
return q
end
So, when I run it:
q = test()
w( "q( uno )" , q( uno ) )
It doesn't even call the __index metamethod:
---------- Capture Output ----------
q( uno ) nil
> Terminated with exit code 0.
So, what I'm doing wrong?

Answer 1

If I'm understanding correctly, then what you're trying to do doesn't make much sense. uno will be looked up in the environment that q is called in, not with. In your example it's like calling q(nil). The example from the other question works because they're working in the same, global environment.
You can use write a helper function to intercept your current environments nil-lookups, but it must be called preemptively in any environment you want to use these nil-to-string lookups.
local function intercept (tab)
setfenv(2, setmetatable(tab or {}, {
__index = function (_, key)
return key
end
}))
end
And you'll need an environment cloning function, unless you want to manually create your sandboxes every time, else you'll probably mess up parent environments (e.g., _G). You could move this logic inside of intercept for a cleaner function call, but with less flexibility.
local function clone_current_env ()
local env = {}
for key, value in pairs(getfenv(2)) do
env[key] = value
end
return env
end
Using them together, you can cause nil lookups in whichever environment you're in to become strings.
intercept(clone_current_env())
print(type(foo), type(bar)) --> string string
This is some ugly metaprogramming, and I don't really know why you'd want to write code like this, except as a proof of concept.
A full example.
DEMO
local function clone (tab)
local new = {}
for key, value in pairs(tab) do
new[key] = value
end
return new
end
local function enable_nil_strings ()
setfenv(2, setmetatable(clone(getfenv(2)), {
__index = function (env, key)
return key
end
}))
end
local function disable_nil_strings()
setmetatable(getfenv(2), nil)
end
-----------------------------------------------------
print(type(foo), type(bar)) --> nil nil
enable_nil_strings()
print(type(foo), type(bar)) --> string string
disable_nil_strings()
print(type(foo), type(bar)) --> nil nil
Finally, arguably the best way to implement this would be to simply wrap around an execution context:
local function with_nil_strings (context, ...)
local env = {}
for key, value in pairs(getfenv(2)) do
env[key] = value
end
setfenv(
context,
setmetatable(env, {
__index = function (_, key) return key end
})
)
context(...)
end
print(type(foo)) --> nil
with_nil_strings(function ()
print(type(foo)) --> string
end)
print(type(foo)) --> nil