iOS: How to play audio without fps drops? - ios

Question

I am in the process of developing a game for iOS 9+ using Sprite Kit and preferably using Swift libraries.
Currently I'm using a Singleton where I preload my audio files, each connected to a separate instance of AVAudioPlayer.
Here's a short code-snipped to get the idea:
import SpriteKit
import AudioToolbox
import AVFoundation
class AudioEngine {
static let sharedInstance = AudioEngine()
internal var sfxPing: AVAudioPlayer
private init() {
self.sfxPing = AVAudioPlayer()
if let path = NSBundle.mainBundle().pathForResource("ping", ofType: "m4a") {
do {
let url = NSURL(fileURLWithPath:path)
sfxPing = try AVAudioPlayer(contentsOfURL: url)
sfxPing.prepareToPlay()
} catch {
print("ERROR: Can't load ping.m4a audio file.")
}
}
}
}
This Singleton is initialised during app start-up. In the game-loop I then just call the following line to play a specific audio file:
AudioEngine.sharedInstance.sfxPing.play()
This basically works, but I always get glitches when a file is played and the frame rate drops from 60.0 to 56.0 on my iPad Air.
Someone any idea how to fix this performance issue with AVAudioPlayer ?
I also watched out for 3rd party libraries, namely:
AudioKit [Looks very heavy-weighted]
ObjectAL [Last Update 2013 ...]
AVAudioEngine [Based on AVAudioPlayer, same problems ?]
Requirements:
Play a lot of very short samples (like shots, hits, etc..)
Play some motor effects (thus pitching would be nice)
Play some background / ambient sound in a loop
NO nasty glitches / frame rate drops !
Could you recommend any of the above mentioned libraries for my requirements or point out the problems using the above code ?
UPDATE:
Playing short sounds with:
self.runAction(SKAction.playSoundFileNamed("sfx.caf", waitForCompletion: false))
does indeed improve the frame rate. I exported the audio files with Audiacity to the .caf format (Apple's Core Audio Format). But in the tutorial, they export with "Signed 32-bit PCM" encoding which led to disturbed audio playback in my case. Using any of the other encoding options (32-bit float, U-Law, A-Law, etc..) worked fine for me.
Why using caf format? Because it's uncompressed and thus loaded faster into memory with less CPU overhead compared to compressed formats like m4a. For short sound effects played a lot in short intervals, this makes sense and disk usage is not affected much for short audio files consuming few kilobytes. For bigger audio files, like ambient and background music, using compressed formats (mp3, m4a) is obviously the better choice.

Answer 1

According to your question, if you develop a game for iOS 9+, you can use the new iOS 9 library SKAudioNode (official Apple doc):
var backgroundMusic: SKAudioNode!
For example you can add this to didMoveToView():
if let musicURL = NSBundle.mainBundle().URLForResource("music", withExtension: "m4a") {
backgroundMusic = SKAudioNode(URL: musicURL)
addChild(backgroundMusic)
}
You can also use to play a simple effect:
let beep = SKAudioNode(fileNamed: "beep.wav")
beep.autoplayLooped = false
self.addChild(beep)
Finally, if you want to change the volume:
beep.runAction(SKAction.changeVolumeTo(0.4, duration: 0))
Update:
I see you have update your question speaking about AVAudioPlayer and SKAction. I've tested both of them for my iOS8+ compatible games.
About AVAudioPlayer, I personally use a custom library maked by me based from the old SKTAudio.
I see your code, about AVAudioPlayer init, and my code is different because I use:
#available(iOS 7.0, *)
public init(contentsOfURL url: NSURL, fileTypeHint utiString: String?)
I don't know if fileTypeHint make the difference, so try and fill me about your test.
Advantages about your code:
With a shared instance audio manager based to AVAudioPlayer you can control volume, use your manager wherever you want, ensure compatibility with iOS8
Disadvantages about your code:
Everytime you play a sound and you want to play another sound, the previous is broken, especially if you have launch a background music.
How to solve? According with this SO post to work well without issues seems AVFoundation is limited to 4 AVAudioPlayer properties instantiables, so you can do this:
1) backgroundMusicPlayer: AVAudioPlayer!
2) soundEffectPlayer1: AVAudioPlayer!
3) soundEffectPlayer2: AVAudioPlayer!
4) soundEffectPlayer3: AVAudioPlayer!
You could build a method that switch through the 3 soundEffect to see if is occupied:
if player.playing
and use the next free player. With this workaround you have always your sound played correctly, even your background music.