I have a UIView with a bunch of subviews. Each subview can either be clicked (UITouchUpInside) or 'swiped' (UITouchDragExit) to perform a different action. Both actions work as intended separately, but since the subviews are really close together, the UITouchDragExit Control event of one view accidentally activates the UITouchUpInside of the subview above it.
In order to avoid this, I was thinking of making the subview ignore all other touches to its other subviews until the UITouchDragExit gesture is over. What would be the best way of accomplishing this? In other words how can I detect the start/end of UITouchDragExit?
Thanks in advance!
Related
I'm trying to pass tap events to the superview but handle longpress events. I've added LongPressGestureRecognizer to the top view but the tap events aren't passed to the superview. I tried multiple approaches:
Overriding hitTest doesn't work since the longpress gesture recognizer handler doesn't get called
isUserInteractionEnabled - same as above
Overriding touchesBegan/Ended and calling them manually on the superview doesn't trigger the tap event
Handing complex tap interactions can be hard, and mixing different approaches can make it much much harder.
Generally, the best way to handle it is to have a single view that has multiple gesture recognisers on them. Implement the UIGestureRecognizerDelegate method gestureRecognizer(_:shouldRecognizeSimultaneouslyWith:) and gestureRecognizer(_:shouldRequireFailureOf:) to handle conflicts. When a touch event is recognised it can delegate the action to whatever other object needs to deal with it. Having different views all trying to deal with touches at the same time is not a good way to deal with the problem. Gestures are dependent on other gestures and cannot all be handled independently by different views.
I have a super view that has a UITapGestureRecognizer on it. It allows touches within the view because there are clickable items within the view.
When these items are clicked on, I want to take a specific action, not the generic one that covers the entire superview. Unfortunately in my TouchDown event of my child control I don't know how to stop the event here. I know I could create a kludge flag, but this seems like the wrong way to go.
Any advice?
James
OK I got a solution. Totally my problem. I was playing around with trying to get all touches to work and at one point I had set cancelTouchesInView = true on the UITapGestureRecognizer superview. While this didn't stop the other touches from happening, for whatever reason the touches carried through to the superview as well. I understand that this explanation probably makes no sense, but that's what did it. Still trying to wrap my head around how iOS does touch.
I'm rather confident [editable] UITextView's become firstResponder when a long press or tap gesture occurs within the scrollView. I want to identify where in the view this touch occured. Digging through the documentation and source code didn't yield me much. I might be going about this wrong. My concern is a race condition if I just add my own tap recognizer (how can I be sure it is called before the textView's delegate methods).
For practical clarification, I want to call two similar functions from a delegate function (editingDidBegin) but depending if they touched the left or right half of the text view, I want to call either of the two.
This is a pretty hypothetical question just to understand proper design but lets say I have two custom UIViews.
One of them is essentially a container that I'll call a drawer. Its purpose is to hide and show content. It's a lot like the notification center on iOS where you swipe to pull it open and flick it back up to close it. It's a generic container than can contain any other UIView. It has a UIPanGestureRecognizer to track the finger that's pulling it open/closed. It might also have a UISwipeGestureRecognizer to detect a "flick".
The other view is a custom map widget that has UIPan/Rotation/Pinch GestureRecognizers.
I think the drawer view should be the UIGestureRecognizerDelegate for the Pan/Swipe GestureRecognizers so that it can prevent touches from being delivered unless the user is grabbing "the handle".
My first instinct is for the map to be the UIGestureRecognizerDelegate of the pan/rotation/pinch gestures so that it can allow them to all run simultaneously.
The problem I'm having is that, I really don't want the map to receive any touches or begin recognizing gestures until the drawer is completely open. I'd like to be able to enforce this behavior automatically in the drawer itself so that it works for all subviews right out of the box.
The only way that I can think to do this is to wire all of the gestures handlers to the ViewController and let it do everything, but to me that breaks encapsulation as now it has to know that the map gestures need to run simultaneously, that the drawer should only get touches on it's handle and that the map should only get touches when it's open.
What are some ways of doing this where the logic can stay in the Views where I think it belongs?
I would do something like this to make the subviews of the drawer disabled while panning. Essentially loop through the drawer's subviews and disbale interaction on them.
[self.subviews enumerateObjectsUsingBlock:^(UIView *subview, NSUInteger idx, BOOL *stop){
subview.userInteractionEnabled = NO;
}];
And something similar again for when you want to re-enable user interaction on the subviews.
This should already Just Workâ˘. A gesture recogniser is attached to a view; when a continuous gesture is recognised, all subsequent touches associated with that gesture are associated with that view.
So in your case, when the drawer pan is recognised, no touches associated with that pan should ever cause behaviour in your map view's pan/pinch/rotation gestures (unless you explicitly specify that they should using the appropriate delegate methods).
Or do you mean that you want to prevent the user from, halfway through opening the drawer, using another finger (i.e. another gesture) to start scrolling the (half-visible) map? If so, you should just set userInteractionEnabled on the drawer's contentView (or equivalent) to NO at UIGestureRecognizerStateBegan/Changed and YES again at UIGestureRecognizerStateEnded/Cancelled.
I know what I want to do, but I'm stumped as to how to do it: I want to implement something like the iOS multitasking gestures. That is, I want to "steal" touches from any view inside my view hierarchy if the number of touches is greater than, say, two. Of course, the gestures are not meant to control multitasking, it's just the transparent touch-stealing I'm after.
Since this is a fairly complex app (which makes extensive use of viewController containment), I want this to be transparent to the views that it happens to (i. e. I want to be able to display arbitrary views and hierarchies, including UIScrollViews, MKMapViews, UIWebViews etc. without having to change their implementation to play nice with my gestures).
Just adding a gestureRecognizer to the common superview doesn't work, as subviews that are interaction enabled eat all the touches that fall on them.
Adding a visually transparent UI-enabled view as a sibling (but in front) of the main view hierarchy also doesn't work, since now this view eats all the touches. I've experimented with reimplementing touchesBegan: etc. in the touchView, but forwarding the touches to nextResponder doesn't work, because that'll be the common superview, in effect funnelling the touches right around the views that are supposed to be receiving them when the touchView gives them up.
I am sure I'm not the only one looking for a solution for this, and I'm sure there are smarter people than me that have this already figured out. I even suspect it might not actually be very hard, and just maybe my brain won't see the forest for the trees today. I'm thankful for any helpful answers anyway :)
I would suggest you to try using method swizzling, reimplementing the touchesbegan on UIView. I think that the best way is to store in a static shared variable the number of touches (so that each view can increment/decrement this value). It's just a very simple idea, take it with a grain of salt.
Hope this helps.
Ciao! :)
A possible, but potentially dangerous (if you aren't careful) approach is to subclass your application UIWindow and redefine the sendEvent: method.
As this method is called for each touch event received by the app, you can inspect it and then decide to call [super sendEvent:] (if the touch is not filtered), or don't call it (if the touch is filtered) or just defer its call if you are still recognizing the touch.
Another possibility is to play with the hitTest:withEvent: method but this would require your stealing view to be placed properly in the subview, and I think it doesn't fit well when you have many view controllers. I believe the previous solution is more general purpose.
Actually, adding a gesture recognizer on the common superview is the right way to do this. But it sound like you may need to set either delaysTouchesBegan or cancelsTouchesInView (or both) to ensure that the gesture recognizer handles everything before letting it through to the child views.