Erlang basic general server debugger output interpretation - erlang

Question

I'm having some trouble with an Erlang module. Here is the one that I wrote:
-module(basic_gen_server).
-export([start/1, call/2, cast/2]).
start(Module) ->
register(server, spawn(basic_gen_server,gen_server_loop,[Module, Module:init()])), server.
call(Pid,Request) ->
Pid ! {call, self(), Request},
receive
Reply -> Reply
end.
cast(Pid,Request) ->
Pid ! {cast, self(), Request},
receive
_ -> ok
end.
gen_server_loop(Module, CurrentState) ->
io:fwrite("gen_server_loop~n", []),
receive
{call, CallPid, Request} ->
{reply, Reply, NewState} = Module:handle_call(Request,self(),CurrentState),
CallPid ! Reply,
gen_server_loop(Module, NewState);
{cast, CastPid, Request} ->
{noReply, NewState} = Module:handle_cast(Request, CurrentState),
CastPid ! noReply,
gen_server_loop(Module, NewState)
end.
And here is the callback module that was defined:
% Written by Caleb Helbling
% Last updated Oct 10, 2014
-module(name_server).
-export([init/0, add/3, whereis/2, handle_cast/2,
handle_call/3, handle_swap_code/1]).
%% client routines
add(ServerPid, Person, Place) ->
basic_gen_server:cast(ServerPid, {add, Person, Place}).
whereis(ServerPid, Person) ->
basic_gen_server:call(ServerPid, {whereis, Person}).
%% callback routines
init() ->
maps:new().
handle_cast({add, Person, Place}, State) ->
NewState = maps:put(Person, Place, State),
{noreply, NewState}.
handle_call({whereis, Person}, _From, State) ->
Reply = case maps:find(Person, State) of
{ok, Place} -> Place;
error -> error
end,
NewState = State,
{reply, Reply, NewState}.
handle_swap_code(State) ->
{ok, State}.
Upon trying to initialize the server with the following command:
MyServer = basic_gen_server:start(name_server).
I get the following debug output:
=ERROR REPORT==== 29-Oct-2014::12:41:42 ===
Error in process <0.70.0> with exit value: {undef,[{basic_gen_server,gen_server_loop,[name_server,#{}],[]}]}
Conceptually, I understand the notion of making serial code into a basic server system, but I believe that I have a syntax error that I haven't been able to find using either syntax highlighting or Google. Thanks in advance for the help!

Answer 1

Function gen_server_loop is not exported. So you can not call basic_gen_server:gen_server_loop(Module, Module:init()), which is what is happening inside spawn(basic_gen_server,gen_server_loop,[Module, Module:init()]).
If you read your error message it tells you that function you are trying to call in undefined (trougn undef atom). Function being {basic_gen_server,gen_server_loop,[name_server,#{}],[]}, or where you have {Module, Function, ListOfArgs, ...}. You always should check that
there are no types module or function name
function arity match number of arguments in call (List in error message)
function is exported
All local calls (like loop(SomeArgs), without module specified) will not compile if function is not defined. And you can do local call dynamically (FuntionName(SomeArgs) again without module name).
EDIT after comment about need of local calls.
You actually could use lambda for this. There is spawn/1 funciton, which takes lambda (or fun if you like), so you can call spawn( fun local_functino/0).. Only issue with that is fact that your fun can not take any arguments, but there is a way around it, with use of closures.
spawn(fun () ->
gen_server_loop(Module, Module:init())
end).
And gen_serve_loop stays local call.