MVC detect when model is empty - asp.net-mvc

Question

I'm new to MVC, so I'm trying to figure out some best practices.
Suppose I have a controller HomeController method Index(MyViewModel model):
public ActionResult Index(MyViewModel model)
{
//if loading the page for the first time, do nothing
//if the page has been posted data from somewhere, then I want to use
// some of the arguments in model to load other data, like say search results
}
When I navigate to the /Index page, I (myself) expect the model object to come through as null, but it doesn't. MVC (somehow) creates a MyViewModel for me.
My question is, what's the best way or most consistent to determine if model was created automatically, or via a post?
Ideas:
Create a property on MyViewModel that gets set when the view is posting back
Check for if the Request.HttpMethod == "GET" or "POST"
Something else?

Answer 1

You should use different actions for your GET and POST requests. Don't try and make a single method do too much.
[HttpGet]
public ActionResult Index()
{
// handle the GET request
}
[HttpPost]
public ActionResult Index(MyViewModel model)
{
if (ModelState.IsValid)
{
// it's a post and the data is valid
}
}
The correct method will then be called depending on whether it's a GET or POST

Answer 2

Create two actions, one which accepts a model instance and one which doesn't.
Even though you're "going to the same page" you are in fact performing two distinctly different actions. The first action loads an initial page, the second action posts some value to be acted upon. Two actions means two methods:
[HttpGet]
public ActionResult Index()
{
// perform any logic, but you probably just want to return the view
return View();
}
[HttpPost]
public ActionResult Index(MyViewModel model)
{
// respond to the model in some way
return View(model);
// or return something else? a redirect? it's up to you
}
Note that this kind of breaks your restful URLs. Consider semantically what you're doing in these actions:
Viewing an index
Posting to an index
The first one makes sense, but the second one probably doesn't. Normally when you POST something you're doing something related to a model or action of some sort. "Index" doesn't really describe an action. Are you "Create"-ing something? Are you "Edit"-ing something? Those sound like more meaningful action names for the POST action.