Authorization causes bloated controller tests - ruby-on-rails

I've got a filter which ensures that only super admins can access a particular action:
before_action :require_super_admin
def index; end
In my controller tests I've got:
test "should let super admin access index" do
login_super_admin
get :index
assert_response :success
end
test "should NOT let normal admin access index" do
login_normal_admin
get :index
assert_response :redirect
end
test "should NOT let user access index" do
login_user
get :index
assert_response :redirect
end
test "should NOT let guest access index" do
login_guest
get :index
assert_response :redirect
end
That's four tests to ensure that only a super admin can access the index. Is there a better way of testing this? Does anyone else ever find themselves doing this sort of thing? I run into it every time I build a rails app.

You can create shared examples
shared_example "allow super admins" do |actions|
actions.each do |action|
it "should let super admin access #{action}" do
login_super_admin
get action.to_sym
assert_response :success
end
end
end
shared example "deny non super admins" do |actions, users|
actions.each do |action|
users.each do |user|
it "should let not let #{user} access #{action}" do
send("login_#{user}")
get action.to_sym
assert_response :redirect
end
end
end
end
And in your tests that need authorization check, you can do
it_behaves_like "allow super admins", ["index"]
it behaves_like "deny non super admins", ["index"], ["normal_admin", "user", "guest"]
PS: I haven't tested this. This is just to give you an idea

My solution:
# Gemfile
gem 'shoulda-context'
# In test_helper.rb
class ActiveSupport::TestCase
def make_sure_authorization_kicks_in
assert_redirected_to root_url
assert_equal "You are not authorized to perform this action.", flash[:error]
end
end
# In controller tests
context "NOT Super Admin" do
# saves a lot of typing
teardown { make_sure_pundit_kicks_in }
context "just NORMAL ADMIN" do
setup { login_normal_admin }
should("NOT get index"){ get :index }
should("NOT get new"){ get :new }
end
context "just normal USER" do
setup { login_user }
should("NOT get index"){ get :index }
should("NOT get new"){ get :new }
end
end
This is much easier to manage.

Related

Rspec test fails due to to redirection to a page for loggin in (Rails + Devise + Cancancan)

I am writing test for controllers in Rails:
require 'rails_helper'
RSpec.describe GoodsController, type: :controller do
DatabaseCleaner.clean
user = User.create(password: "12345678")
user.save!
describe "GET index" do
it "renders the index template" do
sign_in user
get "index"
expect(response).to render_template("index")
end
end
DatabaseCleaner.clean
end
the GoodsController has this index action I want to test:
def index
if params[:category_id] == nil
#goods = Good.all
else
#goods = Good.where(category_id: params[:category_id])
end
end
and when I run the test, I receive this error:
1) GoodsController GET index renders the index template
Failure/Error: expect(response).to render_template("index")
expecting <"index"> but was a redirect to <http://test.host/users/sign_in>
# ./spec/controllers/goods_controller_spec.rb:12:in `block (3 levels) in <top (required)>'
I've added that sign_in user line, according to other answers in SO, but it didn't help. It still redirects to the logging page. How do I resolve this?
The user you create is not used by rspec when running the Examples (aka tests). It's just a variable inside a block that doesn't do anything useful.
When dealing with fixtures/factories you should either create them in before, let or inside the test itself (it block).
describe "GET index" do
let(:user) { User.create(password: "12345678") }
it "renders the index template" do
# OR, create it here before sign_in
sign_in user
get "index"
expect(response).to render_template("index")
end
end
Not sure if you are using factory_bot, but you should look at it. Usually DatabaseCleaner is set up inside rails_helper, check this SO post for more details.
If you are going to have multiple tests that need the user to be signed in you could also wrap the sign_in in a before hook.
describe "GET index" do
let(:user) { User.create(password: "12345678") }
before do
sign_in user
end
it "renders the index template" do
get "index"
expect(response).to render_template("index")
end
end

How to test activeadmin AuthorizationAdapter?

I have a custom AutorizationAdapter that I would like to test using RSpec:
class AdminAuthorization < ActiveAdmin::AuthorizationAdapter
def authorized?(_action, _subject = nil)
user.admin?
end
end
Initially I used a custom method but since I'm using Devise, using a custom AuthorizationAdapter seemed to be the way to go.
How would you go about testing it ? I tought one way to test it is to create a request spec for one of the controller and test for status code & redirection, something like that:
require 'rails_helper'
RSpec.describe 'AdminUsers', type: :request do
describe 'GET /admin_users' do
context 'admin' do
let(:admin_user) { create(:admin_user) }
before { sign_in super_user }
get admin_users_path
expect(response).to have_http_status(200)
end
context 'non admin' do
let(:user) { create(:user) }
before { sign_in user }
it 'redirects to the login page' do
get admin_users_path
expect(response).to have_http_status(302)
expect(response).to redirected_to '/admin/login'
end
end
context 'non logged in user' do
it 'redirects to the login page' do
get admin_users_path
expect(response).to have_http_status(302)
expect(response).to redirected_to '/admin/login'
end
end
end
end
I'm not sure this is the way to go.
These look reasonable to me. You can also look at the unit and feature specs that are in the ActiveAdmin test suite. However, AuthorizationAdapter itself is a PORO so you should be able to unit test in isolation: in the example given above that would be a fairly trivial test.

How to create a route for testing purposes?

I'm writing tests with rspec for my application controller in my rails app (written in Rails 4) and I'm running into a problem where it doesn't recognize the route for the HTTP request I'm sending. I know there's a way to do this using MyApp::Application.routes but I'm not able to get it working.
#application_controller_spec.rb
require 'spec_helper'
class TestController < ApplicationController
def index; end
end
describe TestController do
before(:each) do
#first_user = FactoryGirl.create(:user)
# this is to ensure that all before_filters are run
controller.stub(:first_time_user)
controller.stub(:current_user)
end
describe 'first_time_user' do
before(:each) do
controller.unstub(:first_time_user)
end
context 'is in db' do
before(:each) do
#user = FactoryGirl.create(:user)
controller.stub(:current_user).and_return(#user)
end
it 'should not redirect' do
get :index
response.should_not be_redirect
end
end
context 'is not in db' do
context 'session[:cas_user] does not exist' do
it 'should return nil' do
get :index
expect(assigns(:current_user)).to eq(nil)
end
end
it "should redirect_to new_user_path" do
controller.stub(:current_user, redirect: true).and_return(nil)
get :index
response.should be_redirect
end
end
end
The error I'm getting right now is
No route matches {:action=>"index", :controller=>"test"}
I would add the test#index route to config/routes.rb, but it doesn't recognize the Test Controller, so I want to do something like
MyApp::Application.routes.append do
controller :test do
get 'test/index' => :index
end
end
but I'm not sure where to add this or if this even works in rspec. Any help would be great!
If you are trying to test your ApplicationController, see this RSpec documentation about it. You will need to define methods like index inside the test, but it works well.

Generating RSpec Examples via Functions

I'm trying to add a function to allow for quick testing of redirects for unauthenticated users. Here's what I have so far:
def unauthenticated_redirects_to redirect_path #yeild
context "when not signed in" do
it "redirects to #{redirect_path}" do
yield
expect(response).to redirect_to redirect_path
end
end
end
describe SomeController do
describe 'GET #show' do
unauthenticated_redirects_to('/some_path') { get :show }
context "when signed in" do
# One thing...
# Another thing...
end
end
describe 'GET #whatever' do
unauthenticated_redirects_to('/some_other_path') { get :whatever }
end
end
This doesn't work, however, since the scope and context of the primary describe block is not available to the block passed to unauthenticated_redirects_to. This reasonably leads to the error: undefined method `get' for RSpec::Core::ExampleGroup::Nested_1::Nested_2:Class.
Is there a way around this or is there a cleaner way to accomplish something similar which I should consider?
Here's an approach using shared examples which triggers the example based on shared metadata (:auth => true in this case) and which parses the example group description to pick up some key parameters.
require 'spec_helper'
class SomeController < ApplicationController
end
describe SomeController, type: :controller do
shared_examples_for :auth => true do
it "redirects when not signed in" do
metadata = example.metadata
description = metadata[:example_group][:description_args][0]
redirect_path = metadata[:failure_redirect]
http_verb = description.split[0].downcase.to_s
controller_method = description.match(/#(.*)$/)[1]
send(http_verb, controller_method)
expect(response).to redirect_to redirect_path
end
end
describe 'GET #show', :auth => true, :failure_redirect => '/some_path' do
context "when signed in" do
# One thing...
# Another thing...
end
end
describe 'GET #whatever', :auth => true, :failure_redirect => '/some_other_path' do
end
end
For completeness, here's another shared examples approach, this time using a block parameter with a before call which avoids the original scope problem:
require 'spec_helper'
class SomeController < ApplicationController
end
describe SomeController, type: :controller do
shared_examples_for 'auth ops' do
it "redirects when not signed in" do
expect(response).to redirect_to redirect_path
end
end
describe 'GET #show' do
it_behaves_like 'auth ops' do
let(:redirect_path) {'/some_path'}
before {get :show}
end
context "when signed in" do
# One thing...
# Another thing...
end
end
describe 'GET #new' do
it_behaves_like 'auth ops' do
let(:redirect_path) {'/some_other_path'}
before {get :whatever}
end
end
end
Have a look at rspec shared example.
Using shared_examples_for seemed like overkill given that I was only concerned with a single example. Furthermore, it_behaves_like("unauthenticated redirects to", '/some_other_path', Proc.new{ get :whatever}) seems unnecessarily verbose. The trick is to use #send() to maintain the proper scope.
def unauthenticated_redirects_to path, method_action
context "when not signed in" do
it "redirects to #{path} for #{method_action}" do
send(method_action.first[0], method_action.first[1])
expect(response).to redirect_to path
end
end
end
describe 'GET #new' do
unauthenticated_redirects_to '/path', :get => :new
end

How to DRY up RSpec tests shared by different actions in same controller

I have the following tests that I want tested from various actions in the same controller. How can I DRY this up? In the comments below you'll see that the test should call a different method and action depending on which action I'm testing.
shared_examples_for "preparing for edit partial" do
it "creates a new staff vacation" do
StaffVacation.should_receive(:new)
get :new
end
it "assigns #first_day_of_week" do
get :new
assigns(:first_day_of_week).should == 1
end
end
describe "GET new" do
# i want to use 'it_behaves_like "preparing for edit partial"'
# and it should use 'get :new'
end
describe "GET edit" do
# i want to use 'it_behaves_like "preparing for edit partial"'
# but it should use 'get :edit' instead
end
describe "POST create" do
# on unsuccessful save, i want to use 'it_behaves_like "preparing for edit partial"'
# but it should use 'post :create' instead
end
You could do something like this:
shared_examples_for "preparing for edit partial" do
let(:action){ get :new }
it "creates a new staff vacation" do
StaffVacation.should_receive(:new)
action
end
it "assigns #first_day_of_week" do
action
assigns(:first_day_of_week).should == 1
end
end
context 'GET new' do
it_should_behave_like 'preparing for edit partial' do
let(:action){ get :new }
end
end
context 'GET edit' do
it_should_behave_like 'preparing for edit partial' do
let(:action){ get :edit }
end
end
context 'POST create' do
it_should_behave_like 'preparing for edit partial' do
let(:action){ post :create }
end
end
Or, you could use some kind of loop for the examples:
['get :new', 'get :edit', 'post :create'].each do |action|
context action do
it "creates a new staff vacation" do
StaffVacation.should_receive(:new)
eval(action)
end
it "assigns #first_day_of_week" do
eval(action)
assigns(:first_day_of_week).should == 1
end
end
end
One option might be to provide a module mix-in with a method that has your spec inside it.
include Auth # This is your module with your generalized spec inside a method
it "redirects without authentication" do
unauthorized_redirect("get", "new")
end
Then, in our method, we could do a loop through different types of authorization:
module Auth
def unauthorized_redirect(request, action)
[nil, :viewer, :editor].each do |a|
with_user(a) do
eval "#{request} :#{action}"
response.should redirect_to login_path
# whatever other expectations
end
end
end
end

Resources