wrong ids when render h:panelGroup's inside c:forEach - jsf-2

I have page where I render some h:panelGroup panels. Those panels are realized as plugins registered in a plugin registry on startup.
Part of the plugins api is a custom jsf component where I get the registered plugins for extension point and include their facelet templates by path:
<c:forEach items="#{pluginRegistry.getPlugins(point)}" var="extension">
<ui:include src="#{extension.path}" />
</c:forEach>
The page where I include the panels looks like:
<h:panelGrid id="dashboard" columns="3">
<cmf:insertPageFragments point="dashboardExtensionPoint" />
</h:panelGrid>
For every panel there are facelet templates like the one below:
<rich:panel id="caseDetailsPanel" header="panel label">
<!-- panel content -->
</rich:panel>
Now, the problem is that the very first panel in the list returned by the pluginsRegistry is rendered in the page with the provided id like formId:caseDetailsPanel for example. The rest of them have generated ids like formId:j_idt223 !!! Obviously if I want to rerender some of the panels, I can't do that.
That happens when environment is jboss AS 7.1 with JSF 2.1, richfaces 4.2.3.Final.
When deployed on jboss-eap-6.1 everything looks fine but for now I can't use this jboss version.
Any suggestions on how to workaround this issue?

There can not be multiple JSF components with the same ID. Each JSF component must have an unique ID. When dynamically creating JSF components using JSTL, you need to manually assign and ensure an unique ID, otherwise JSF will discard the provided ID and autogenerate an unique ID.
There are several ways to achieve this, depending on the concrete functional requirement and the existing code.
Use use the iteration index of <c:forEach>.
<c:forEach ... varStatus="loop">
...
<rich:panel id="caseDetailsPanel_#{loop.index}" ...>
This will generate caseDetailsPanel_0, caseDetailsPanel_1, etc depending on the current iteration index.
Use the unique identifier of the currently iterated item. It isn't clear based on the information provided so far if you have any, so here's just a fictive example assuming that the class behind #{extension} has an id property representing the technical DB identifier.
<c:forEach ... var="extension">
...
<rich:panel id="caseDetailsPanel_#{extension.id}" ...>
Wrap #1 or #2 if necessary in a <f:subview> with an unique identifier, so that you don't need to modify the includes.
<c:forEach ... varStatus="loop">
<f:subview id="panel_#{loop.index}">
<ui:include ... />
The <f:subview> creates a new NamingContainer around it, so you end up getting formId:panel_0:caseDetailsPanel, formId:panel_1:caseDetailsPanel and so on.
A completely different alternative would be to use <ui:repeat> instead of <c:forEach>. The <ui:repeat> does not run during view build time, but during view render time. This way there's physically only one <rich:panel id="caseDetailsPanel"> component in the component tree which is reused multiple times during generating HTML whereby JSF will take care of generating the right IDs with the <ui:repeat> index like so formId:repeatId:0:caseDetailsPanel. However, this in turn may cause trouble with <ui:include> as it also runs during view build time and thus can't get the #{extension} at hands.

Related

<ui:include> with dynamic src ... complete madness [duplicate]

This question already has answers here:
How to ajax-refresh dynamic include content by navigation menu? (JSF SPA)
(3 answers)
Closed 5 years ago.
I'm having a massive problem getting an extremely simple task done in JSF. The problem: I have objects, who have aggregated properties that can vary in type from object to object. Depending on the type of the property, I want to use a different set of input fields.
The subtype components reside in frameworks and get loaded on demand. To this end, I use the following code:
<h:panelGroup id="zusatzdaten">
<fieldset class="clear">
<legend>#{tickerUI.ticker.tickerDescription.label}
(#{tickerUI.ticker.tickerDescId})
</legend>
<h:panelGroup rendered="#{tickerUI.editComponentName != null}">
<ui:include src="#{tickerUI.editComponentName}"/>
</h:panelGroup>
</fieldset>
</h:panelGroup>
The name of the component comes out of TickerUI, which is of #SessionScope. Now the dazzling bit: when it first loads, the correct subcomponent is displayed. However, when using a link in the navigation, which should lead to including a different component, the content is NOT updated! This results in an error, because the data is now a different subtype, but the form components are still from the previous one.
When going back from the error and clicking the link again, the correct component is displayed. I logged the value of editComponentName and the correct values are returned. This is very confusing. Why is including the wrong content when the getter returns the correct component name to the 's src attribute?
Help greatly appreciated.
Actually your problem is a classic view build vs view render time problem/misunderstanding. More specifically, the view is built on every new request and reconstructed from a previously saved state on postbacks. Later the view is rendered to produce HTML content.
Now, as <ui:include> is a tag handler, or in official terms a view build time tag, when you first request the page, its value attribute is evaluated, and the included page makes its way into the view. Upon postback, contrary to what you might expect, the incuded contents are already there, in the reconstructed view. So, it is an expected behaviour that you'll have the exact part of view rendered.
As to the solution, you could just simply include an exhaustive list of static includes that are wrapped in conditionally rendered <ui:fragment> JSF components. For simplicity, all content could be places within a container like <h:panelGroup> that's always rendered for ease of AJAX updates. The code could be assembled as follows:
<h:panelGroup id="ui">
<ui:fragment rendered="#{bean.condition1}">
<ui:include src="/path/to/file1.xhtml"/>
</ui:fragment>
...
<ui:fragment rendered="#{bean.condition_n}">
<ui:include src="/path/to/file_n.xhtml"/>
</ui:fragment>
</h:panelGroup>
A classical dilemma, it seems. BalusC's blog gave the solution for my case in the form of a configuration parameter in web.xml:
<context-param>
<param-name>javax.faces.PARTIAL_STATE_SAVING</param-name>
<param-value>false</param-value>
</context-param>

widgetVar name collision in Primefaces in multiple cc:renderFacet

I have composite component, in which I have toolbar and datatable. I also defined facet which contains a form for manipulating data from datatable. Users define that facet for different kinds of data. Now, I have problem because I render that facet multiple times and now I have collisions for widgetVar names for Primefaces components. It is no possible to use insertChildren multiple times so I think this is only possible solution. Also I wouldn't like to force users of component to define 10 facets and write ui:include 10 times. Is there any other way to insert some facelet code in composite component, or is there any way to pass parameter to facet, and use that parameter to dynamically create widgetVar?
OK, after some time I just didn't succeeded to do what I wanted. First I had some composite component like this:
<cc:interface>
<!-- Attributes definition -->
<cc:facet name="form"/>
</cc:interface>
<cc:implementation>
<p:dialog><f:subview id="detailSubview1"><cc:renderFacet name="form"/></f:subview></p:dialog>
<p:dialog><f:subview id="detailSubview2"><cc:renderFacet name="form"/></f:subview></p:dialog>
<!-- There is some more renderFacets but this is enough -->
</cc:implementation>
If I have for example p:selectOneMenu inside the form, without any widgetVar definitions, all will be with same name for widgetVar and this is a problem.
So, I changed this completely and I will transform this composite component to ui:composition and decorate it in my page. In that case widget vars are generated as I want, with different names, because they are in different naming containers.
A widgetVar is in fact used in JavaScript to identify the component. Therefor a widgetVar must be unique in a page. You'll have to declare it yourself.
If you want to create a custom component, as I think might suit you better than ui:define/ui:include, you might want to do something like this:
Say we want to create a component that renders a p:commandButton and a h:outputText with the same value (for whatever reason). You create a XHTML page in directory [deployed-root]/resources/example, named customComponent.xhtm:
<html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml"
xmlns:h="http://java.sun.com/jsf/html"
xmlns:p="http://primefaces.org/ui"
xmlns:c="http://java.sun.com/jsf/composite">
<c:interface>
<c:attribute name="text" required="true" />
</c:interface>
<c:implementation>
<h:outputText value="#{cc.attrs.text}" />
<p:commandButton value="#{cc.attrs.text}" />
</c:implementation>
</html>
Then to use this in another page you'll have to define the namespace xmlns:e="http://java.sun.com/jsf/composite/example", and then you can refer to the custom component like this: <e:customComponent text="some text here"/>.
It should also be noted that it is bad practice to declare forms in custom components. This affects flexibility of use drastically since forms cannot be nested.
PrimeFaces can generate wigetVars so you don't have to.
From the 3.4 User's Guide:
<p:dialog id="dlg">
<!-- contents -->
</p:dialog>
<p:commandButton type="button" value="Show" onclick="#{p:widgetVar('dlg')}.show();"/>
This is designed to work in naming containers, so it should work just fine in composite components, <ui:repeat/>, <h:dataTable/>, etc.

Ordinal JSF-paging with breadcrumbs composite components

I want to split a big form into several composite components (since I reuse the CCs). One major page (business process page) must allow a user to navigate across 4 CCs. Not necessarily in a sequential order. The user may use the breadcrumbs of the major page to jumb from 1 to 4 - or - use the arrows to navigate sequentially back and forth.
Requirements:
All navigation items (arrows and breadcrumbs) must be placed on the major page.
The major page must never be reloaded. The CCs only.
The user is able to leave the site temporarily without losing the data provided (since there are many fields on these pages).
What's the top-notch approach?
Shell I create #SessionScoped manged bean (controller), which renders CCs instance within a h:panelGroup?
<h:panelGroup id="businessProcessForm" layout="block">
<my:composite rendered="#{controllerBean.navigateToCC}" />
</h:panelGroup>
<h:commandButton value="load previous CC" action="#{controllerBean.setNextCC('CC1')}">
<f:ajax render="businessProcessForm" />
</h:commandButton>
<h:commandButton value="load next CC" action="#{controllerBean.setNextCC('CC3')}">
<f:ajax render="businessProcessForm" />
</h:commandButton>
How do I set the links for the breadcrumbs (they must be created according to the number of CCs)?
How do I set the previous/next links?
How do I populate the h:panelGroup by the arrows or breadcrumbs?
Any solid answers (including Richfaces)?
Providing an answer very late. If you have better alternative of implementing Breadcrumbs in JSF and RichFaces please do let me know.
RichFaces itself does not provide any kind of BreadCrumbs components like the one provided by Trinidad from MyFaces.
An alternative to create a breadcrumb like structure would be to dynamically add images and links in and bind this grid to the backing bean. As and when user navigate from one page to another particularly after doing certain kind of operation, a new component and a corresponding image can be added into this grid and then grid can be rerendered

Unique ID for JSF composite component inside dataTable

I am using PrimeFaces 3.2 with JSF 2 in a glassfish 3.1.2.
I have a <p:dataTable> which displays search results containing information on different issues (the issues are assigned to users).
If somebody clicks on the icon of the assigned user a <p:dialog> pops up.
The user icon and the according dialog are implemented using a composite.
Inside the composite I am using some jQuery functions which need a unique ID for each dialog component - I am not able to find a way to solve this problem.
My investigations so far:
I need to set the widgetVar attribute, which works fine as long as I have only one user in the list but it seems that inside a dataTable the widgetVar is not unique for many composites.
Since the user can be displayed more than one time inside the search result, I am not able to setup an widgetVar like this:
<ui:param name="myWidgetVar" value="widget_#{user.id}" />
and use it this way
<p:dialog widgetVar="#{myWidgetVar}">
also using #{cc.id} does not resolve the problem 'cause it only returns the id of the widget without the naming-container part which is always the same.
I need the complete id as displayed in html (e.g.: form:jdt123:dialog:456) - how can I get this?
Does anyone know what to do?
Thanks Pete
My solution is using #{cc.clientId} which I did not know yet.
This gives me the complete html element id constisting of the series of identifiers glued with the UINamingContainer#getSeparatorChar (e.g.: form:jdt123:dialog:jdt456)
Thanks for the answer. You solved my unrelated problem, but I think I stumbled on another solution for your problem.
From the PrimeFaces user guide (http://primefaces.org/documentation.html):
8.2 EL Functions
PrimeFaces provides built-in EL extensions that are helpers to common use cases.
Common Functions
Component
<h:form id="form1">
<h:inputText id="name" />
</h:form>
//#{p:component(‘name’)} returns ‘form1:name’
WidgetVar
<p:dialog id="dlg">
//contents
</p:dialog>
<p:commandButton type="button" value="Show" onclick="#{p:widgetVar(‘dlg’)}.show()" />
It looks like you would be most interested in the WidgetVar implementation.

A better way to get the real ID of an component in a naming container

I got the following scenario:
I got several tabs (TabView is a naming container )
and in one of the I got a p:inputText which shows a dialog(which is located in other xhtml file) , now I want the dialog to update the p:inputText , the thing is that the id of the p:inputText is unknow (JSF adds some prefix to it)
<h:form id="hoursReportFrm">
<p:inputText id="comment4Dialog" value="#{hoursReportBean.aComment}"
onfocus="dlg1.show();"/>
I can't use this update="hoursReportFrm:comment4Dialog" in the dialog
ATM i looked at the example of this site JSF: working with component IDs (id vs clientId) (its from 2009)
and added binding to to inputtext , like thisbinding="#{lookup.components.comment4Dialog}" and in the p:commandButton of the dialog I changed to update="#{lookup.clientIds.comment4Dialog}"
and It works just fine, but I'm looking for a better way , without the need to bind every component that I would like to access later...
Thanks ahead,
To be quite honest, I think the binding is probably the easiest route, however when I've been in that situation I've found composite components often offer a better solution than bindings. Depending on the situation (and again, its totally case by case) you can use a composite component to get around this problem. This allows you to reuse parts of a page creatively so that your specific updates don't take a lot of work and you can reuse the code.
An example of this might be:
//comp:myDialog
...
<composite:interface>
<composite:attribute name="update" />
<!-- Other attributes -->
</composite:interface>
<composite:implementation>
...
<!-- Implementation -->
<p:commandButton update="#{cc.attrs.update}"/>
...
</composite:implementation>
And here might be the component in use:
//for the sake of argument 'comp' as your library
<h:form id="someForm">
<p:inputText value="#{bean.changeMe}" id="changeMe"/>
</h:form>
<h:form id="dialog">
<!-- dialog here -->
<comp:myDialog update="someForm:changeMe" />
</h:form>
By separating this view into a piece of reusable code you might be able to get around the burden of specifying the full path because it is now much easier to reuse. However, I think it is a toss up of a binding or the composite component depending on the specific case. For reuse, make a new object (component) and reuse it. If you're dealing with a highly dynamic environment: bind it.
I'm not an expert by any means, but generally speaking the above has gotten me out of a lot of tough situations.
EDIT: on a re-read you should also make sure that the tab-view isn't lazily loaded and take a look at the rendering to make sure the path is correct (inspect the ID). I've had problems (in older versions of Primefaces) where sometimes the id was nested inside a p:outputPanel or in rare cases the subview id. It might be a very simple fix by specifying the full path ':subview:form:component' though that shouldn't be the case.

Resources