Confused, new action not rendered after validation failure - ruby-on-rails

So i have the following code:
def new
#all_areas = Area.all
#area = Area.new
end
The reason i am passing in all_areas is it's required for a drop down box in the form, Using mongoid and an Area can be recursively embedded in another Area.
My form has the following code:
<% if #all_areas %>
<%= f.label :parent_area %>
<%= f.collection_select(:parent_area, #all_areas, :_id, :name, prompt: "Select a Parent...") %>
<% end %>
However when i submit 'invalid values, i.e blank name, the 'new' page does not render the select box to select a parent.
What is going on here? Is this a bug?
My create action is pretty simple, if it fails validation i just do the following:
else
render 'new'
Why is #all_areas not passed to the view the second time? i have actually fixed it by changing the code in my create action to the following:
else
#all_areas = Area.all
render 'new'
But this is quite surprising, unless i am missing something?

It's not a bug. The reason for the behaviour is that the create action is actually quite separate from the new action, so the instance variables you assigned in new don't get carried over. render 'new' only renders the view called "new", it doesn't actually call the new action.
new happens when you issue a GET request to /areas/new. create happens when you POST to /areas. Because they're separate requests, the server doesn't remember any state - in fact, you could call create without ever calling new (say if you used curl from the command line).
Basically, your approach is correct, you need to set the #all_areas instance variable in both actions. You might want to extract it out into a separate private method to avoid the duplication.

Related

How does Rails keep the form data when validations fail?

I have an 'create' action method in Rails and do:
def create
#movie = Movie.new(movie_params)
if #movie.save
redirect_to #movie, notice: "Movie successfully created"
else
render :new
end
end
Now, I have a few validations in place for the Movie model. In case those validations fail, and #movie.save returns false, I simply invoke the new template (without touching the new action, since render :new is the same as render template: 'new'.
I don't understand how Rails can keep the form data I already entered when it again renders that new view. What's going on behind the hood that allows it to do this?
Let's try to understand this whole process point-wise
Instance variables defined in the controller action are shared with the rendered views.
In your case I'm assuming that there's a new action something like
def new
#movie = Movie.new
end
And you have a corresponding view new.html.erb where you have created a form like this
= form_for #movie do |f|
Now, as you know the #movie object that you are passing in form_for method is defined in new action. Most of the times we don't pass any parameters to the new method in new action. The form fields are blank when you load the form because the attributes of the object(in your case #movie) are by default blank because we just initialize an empty object(Movie.new).
Let's assume your Movie model has a name attribute, Try doing this in your new action
def new
#movie = Movie.new(name: 'Hello World!')
end
Now when you will load the new action, you will see Hello World! populated in your name text field because your #movie object is initialized with this value.
Also, keep in mind that Rails Convention-Over-Configuration automatically generates the form URL in this case, by default it points to the create action. When you submit the form the request is made to the create action. This takes me to the next point.
When we submit the form all the filled in form values are sent to the action whose route matches with the form URL(in your case URL points to the create action)
In create action you are receiving parameters in the form of a hash with model attributes(Movie attributes) as keys and the filled in information as their values. The first line in your create action is
#movie = Movie.new(movie_params)
This is a very important line of code, try to understand this. Let's assume your form had only one text field, i.e., name. Now movie_params is a method that looks like this
def movie_params
params.require(:movie).permit(:name)
end
Now, the movie_params method will return a hash something like { 'name' => 'Hello World!' }, now you are passing this hash as a parameter to Movie.new method.
So now, after breaking up the code, the first line of your create action looks like
#movie = Movie.new({ name: 'Hello World!' })
That means your #movie instance variable contains an object of Movie class with name attribute set to Hello World!. Here, when after initialization, if you do #movie.name it will return Hello World!.
Now, in the second line you are calling #movie.save that returned false due to failed validation in your case as you have already mentioned in the question. As it returned false the execution will go to the else part. Now this takes me to the next point.
Calling render :action(in your case render :new) in the controller renders only the view that belongs to that action and does not execute that action code.
In your case, you called render :new, so there you are actually rendering the new.html.erb view in create action. In other words, you are just using the code in new.html.erb and not in new action. Here, render :new does not actually invoke the new action, it's still in the create action but rendering the new.html.erb view.
Now, in new.html.erb you have created a form that looks like
= form_for #movie do |f|
Now as my explained under my first point, the instance variables that are declared in the action are shared by the rendered view, in this case #movie object that you have defined in create action is shared by the rendered new.html.erb in create action. In our case, in create action the #movie object was initialized with some values that were received in the parameters(movie_params), now when new.html.erb is rendered in the else, the same #movie object is used in the form by default. You got the point right, you see the magic here?
This is how Rails works and that's why its awesome when we follow the convention! :)
https://gist.github.com/jcasimir/1210155
http://guides.rubyonrails.org/v4.2/layouts_and_rendering.html
Hope the above examples cleared your doubts, if not, feel free to drop your queries in the comment box below.
form_for helper takes data from #movie variable. In create action forms data assigns to #movie variable. When you call render :new form_for takes column's data from #movie variable.
I'm not sure how deep under the hood you want to go, but basically when you POST to the create method the data is passed to the params, the params being just a key:value pairs where the key and the value are strings, but rails has a special syntax and methods for turning into hashes. params data is passed the Movie model to be processed and the result stored in #movie. When the form is rendered the #movie date is passed back to the form - that data is used to repopulate the form.
I would recommend this blog post and the rails guidefor further reading.
I will try to explain little bit:
in method create first of all we set instance variable
#movie = Movie.new(movie_params)
#movie at this moment has fields filled with movie_params
and after validates brakes we say to Rails 'render :new' with variable #movie.
This is the same if we assign attributes into form:
= form_for Movie.new(movie_params) do ...
When you submit your form. You call create method where all values of movie_params are initializes in #movie. Now due to any reason code break then you call render new for same object (#movie). So form come up with values.
Means in whole process your #movie object persisted.

Rails - how to pass created record from the new form to a redirected page

I think this is a pretty simple question but nothing I've read has answered my question directly:
I have a new products page with a standard form. After successfully submitting the form, I redirect to a custom controller action and view called "thanks".
On the "thanks" page, I want to be able to print the name of the product just created and possibly some other attributes.
How do I pass the object just created into my new action? Right now the controller looks like this:
def create
#product = Product.new(params[:product])
if #product.save
flash[:notice] = "Successfully created Product."
redirect_to thanks_path
else
render :action => 'new'
end
end
def thanks
end
You can't send object through redirect.
There are three ways to solve your problem:
Render the 'thanks' template directly(not action #thanks)
render 'thanks' # thanks template
You can send whatever instance variable to this template directly. #thanks is no longer needed in this case.
Drawback: The url won't be changed.
Convey messages through session
If you want to show certain messages, you can prepare it in #create and send it through session or flash(part of session actually). flash is better as you don't need to clear it manually.
Note: You may want to use ActiveRecord as session storage if the message size is big, otherwise you'll meet CookiesOverflow by default setting.
Send very simple message through session say obj_id
Similar to #2 but I thinks this is better than #2. In #thanks, you can construct complex message according to if obj_id is present, what is the id and then find related data through db.
You have two fairly decent options.
First, you could adjust the thanks_path route to take an id parameter, and call it like redirect_to thanks_path(#product). Then you can call it up in your thank you method like any standard show method. It might be worth mentioning that if you are going to be displaying sensitive information on the thank you screen, you may want to use a random uuid, instead of an id, to look up the product.
A better way might be to not redirect at all, but rather adjust your view from simply drawing the form to something like this:
<% if #product && !#product.new_record %>
THANK YOU MESSAGE GOES HERE
<% else %>
EXISTING FORM GOES HERE
<% end %>

Rails Forms for custom actions

I'm trying to link the input of a form to a specific action in my rails app.
Currently if I go to www.myapp.com/check/:idNumber, I'll be able to trigger the action just fine (which means routes is setup properly?). This action is basically a function call to a ruby/rails script with the parameter "idNumber" being passed to it. If the function is successful, it would return a newly created "Person" object and nil otherwise. This is different than the standard new operation as it determines the the attributes based on some information that it obtained from a database somewhere else.
Rake routes does give me the following:
check /check/:idNumber(.:format) person#check {:id=>/\d+/}
What I'm having trouble implementing is the form itself.
<%= form_tag("/check", :method => "get") do %>
<%= text_field_tag(:idNumber) %>
<% end %>
Controller action:
def check
regCheck = RegCheck.new
#person = regCheck.check_id(params[:idNumber])
if #person.name == nil
redirect_to root_path
end
end
submitting the form above would bring me to myapp.com/check?utf8=✓&idNumber=1234 instead. Can someone tell me what am I doing wrong?
I believe that using the check_path helper that is generated from the routes file is your best bet.
The form should look like this then.
<%= form_tag(check_path) do %>
<%= text_field_tag(:idNumber) %>
<% end %>
Rails forms can be finicky, especially when trying to build really customized forms.
This line
= form_for [#object]
Determines where the form goes, as well as the object that is being implemented. If you want to route the form to a different place, you can user the :url option. This options determines the path of the form, however you must keep in mind that the method is determined by the #object. If it is a new object, the method will be POST, an existing object will use a PUT method.
Let's suppose you want to update an existing object, but you want to send in data for a new object belonging to the existing object. That would look like
= form_for [#object], :as => #child_object, :url => my_optional_custom_path do |f|
# etc...
This generates a form sending a PUT request to the custom url (or the update path for #object if no custom url is supplied. The PUT request is sent with the parameter params[:child_object].
Hopefully this helps!
Best,
-Brian
I don't think it's possible the way you're trying.. The URL for the form is created before the user inputs any data.. So you need to remove the :idNumber from your routing..
If you do you get the following route:
check /check(.:format) person#check
Because the regex is removed now, you need to do this in you're controller:
def check
# Make sure ID is digits only
idNumber = params[:idNumber].gsub(/[^\d]/, '')
regCheck = RegCheck.new
#person = regCheck.check_id(idNumber)
if #person.name == nil
redirect_to root_path
end
end
You're form is allright, but you may want to use check_path like TheBinaryhood suggests..
If you really want it to be check/:idNumber you may also be able to submit the form to another action and redirect it to the right path from there..

Rails: Prevent duplicate inserts due to pressing back button and save again

Think about a simple Rails scaffold application with a "new" action containing a form to add records to a database with a "save" button. After the "create" action the controller redirects to the "show" action, where the user can use the "edit" link to edit the just inserted record. So far, so simple.
But if the user instead uses the browser's back button after creating a record to get back to the "new" action, the browser shows the form with the values the user just has entered. Now he changes some values and presses "save" again. He thinks that this would change the record, but of course this creates a new record.
What is the preferred way to prevent such duplicate entries? I'm looking for a general solution, maybe based on cookies or JavaScript.
After some investigations I found a suitable solution based on cookies. Here it is:
In the controller's "new" action, a timestamp with the current time is generated and rendered in the form as hidden field. When the user submits the form, this timestamps gets back to the controller's "create" action. After creating the record, this timestamp is stored in the session cookie. If the user goes back to the "new" form via browser's back button, he gets a stale form, which means its timestamp is older than the one stored in the cookie. This is checked before creating the record and results in an error message.
Here is the controller code:
def new
#post = Post.new
#stale_form_check_timestamp = Time.now.to_i
end
def create
#post = Post.new(params[:post])
if session[:last_created_at].to_i > params[:timestamp].to_i
flash[:error] = 'This form is stale!'
render 'new'
else
#post.save!
#stale_form_check_timestamp = Time.now.to_i
session[:last_created_at] = #stale_form_check_timestamp
end
end
And here the form code:
- form_for #post do |f|
= tag :input, :type => 'hidden', :name => 'timestamp', :value => #stale_form_check_timestamp
= f.input :some_field
= .......
When I had that same problem I created this little gem that solves it. When the user hits back, he's redirected to the edit_path of the record, instead of going back to the new_path.
https://github.com/yossi-shasho/redirect_on_back
You can do something like:
def create
#user = User.new(params[:user])
if result = #user.save
redirect_on_back_to edit_user_path(#user) # If user hits 'back' he'll be redirected to edit_user_path
redirect_to #user
end
end
Your model validations will ensure things like email addresses are unique, but I think this is more about usability and experience than anything else.
Say you are talking about an account creation form. First of all, your form submit button should say something like "Create Account", instead of just "Submit". Then depending on whether it was successful or not, show a message like either "Account successfully created" or "There were errors creating your account". If the user sees this message, they will know what happened.
Sure you can't prevent someone from hitting the back button and hitting enter again, but you should design for the majority of use cases. If they happen to hit back, they will see the button that says "Create Account". You should probably have some other text on the page that says "Please sign up for a new account to get started".
Just my $0.02.
Session or cookie may result in sides effects.
I totally agree : if there is a way to validate with your model, it's the safest way to prevent duplicate records.
Still you can do 2 things. Prevent browser caching : fields will appear empty in the form when the user clicks on the back button. And disable the "Create" button when clicked.
= f.submit "Create", :disable_with => "Processing..."
When your user will press the back button the button will be disabled.
You can use validators to make sure that no duplicate values are inserted. In this case validates_uniqueness_of :field
If you for example want to prevent users from having the same email address you could put the following code in your user model.
validates_uniqueness_of :email
This checks the column for any previous entries that are the same as the one your trying to inert.
Good luck
base on #Georg Ledermann answer i make this little snip of code for redirect to edit path if the user hits back and then hits create.
#objects_controller.rb
def new
#object = Object.new
#stale_form_check = Time.now.to_i
end
def create
#object = Object.new(object_params)
#function defined in application_controller.rb
redirect_to_on_back_and_create(#object)
end
#application_controller.rb
private
def redirect_to_on_back_and_create(object)
if session[:last_stale].present? and session[:last_stale_id].present? and session[:last_stale].to_i == params[:stale_form_check].to_i
redirect_to edit_polymorphic_path(object.class.find(session[:last_stale_id].to_i)), alert: "Este #{object.model_name.human} ya ha sido creado, puedes editarlo a continuación"
else
if object.save
session[:last_stale] = params[:stale_form_check].to_i
session[:last_stale_id] = object.id
redirect_to object, notice: "#{object.model_name.human} Creado con éxito"
else
render :new
end
end
end
And finally add the #stale_form_check param to your form
<%= hidden_field_tag :stale_form_check, #stale_form_check %>
You could always abstracts this method where you need it, but in this way you could avoid lots of repetition in your project if you need this behavior in many parts
Hope it helps the next one, i used to use redirect_on_back gem, but it didn't work for me this time, the _usec param that this gem uses, was always been reset, so it can't compare in every time when it was need
Here's something that worked for me.
You will need to do 2 things: Create a method in your controller and add a conditional statement in that same controller under your 'create' method.
1) Your method should return the total count of that object from that user.
EX:
def user
current_user.object.count
end
2) Add conditional statement in your 'create' method.
EXAMPLE:
def create
#object = Object.create(object_params)
#object.save if user == 0
redirect_to x_path
end
I hope this helps!
Add html: { autocomplete: "off" } in your form_for like this:
<%= form_for #object, url: xxx_path, html: { autocomplete: "off" } do |f| %>

Passing a model attribute to a Rails view using redirect_to

I'm trying to pass a model attribute to a view, after successfully setting it to a new value from inside an action in my controller. But this variable is always nil by the time it gets to the view, so I can't use it to conditionally display stuff. I should add that this attribute is not a field in the database. What am I missing/doing wrong?
Here is the code in my model:
attr_accessor :mode
#getter
def mode
#mode
end
#setter
def mode=(val)
#mode = val
end
...in the controller:
#report.mode = "t"
redirect_to edit_report_path(#report)
...and in my view:
<%= build_report(#report.mode) %>
...but this helper method never gets the variable I just set in the controller. It is nil. What gives? Clearly I'm missing something basic here because this seems like it should be straightforward. Any insight would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks.
edit_report_path generates a URL with the ID of #report in it.
redirect_to essentially creates a whole new request, and goes to that URL. When it gets to edit, all it has is the ID. Usually that's fine - it looks up the object and keeps going, but of course it's not going to have the non-db field you set.
There are a couple ways to fix this. You can use :render instead to get to the edit page - then #report will have the field set.
#report.mode = "t"
render :action => edit and return
Or, you can make mode a database field.
The problem here is in the redirect_to. When you redirect somewhere else all instance variables are lost. So when you set #report.mode = "t" it sets the attribute. But when you redirect that data is lost.
I am assuming the <%= build_report(#report.mode) %> is in edit_report.html.erb and the code from when you set 'mode' is not in the edit action. If this is the case you may be able to pass the report.mode to the edit action in the url like so:
build_report(#report.mode, :mode => "t")
The problem is the redirect_to; you're returning a response to the client that causes it to redo the request with a different url. In that second request the mode isn't set because you didn't save it before wrapping up the first request.

Resources