DiskCache plugin imageresizer in MVC3 - asp.net-mvc

Question

For my MVC project (Image Server Application), I cannot do caching using imageresizer. I can access my images like this and the image source could be either FileSystem/Database (Dependency injeciton) :
localhost/images/123.jpg?width=500
localhost/images/123?width=500
I have an MVC 3 project with routes like
routes.RouteExistingFiles = true;
routes.IgnoreRoute("{resource}.axd/{*pathInfo}");
routes.IgnoreRoute("favicon.ico");
routes.MapRoute(
"ImagesWithExtension", // Route name
"images/{imageName}.{extension}/", // URL with parameters
new { controller = "Home", action = "ViewImageWithExtension", imageName = "", extension = "", id = UrlParameter.Optional } // Parameter defaults
);
routes.MapRoute(
"Images", // Route name
"images/{imageName}/", // URL with parameters
new { controller = "Home", action = "ViewImage", imageName = "", id = UrlParameter.Optional } // Parameter defaults
);
I have two controllers to deal with images
public ActionResult ViewImageWithExtension(string imageName, string extension) {}
public ActionResult ViewImage(string imageName) {}
The caching is done when the URL is like :
localhost/images/123.jpg?width=500 and the image source is FileSystem
localhost/images/123?width=500 Cache not working image source is Filesystem
localhost/images/123.jpg?width=500 Cache not working, image source DB
localhost/images/123?width=500 Cache not working , image source DB
My web config is like this:
<configSections>
<section name="resizer" type="ImageResizer.ResizerSection" /> </configSections>
<resizer>
<!-- Unless you (a) use Integrated mode, or (b) map all reqeusts to ASP.NET,
you'll need to add .ashx to your image URLs: image.jpg.ashx?width=200&height=20
Optional - this is the default setting -->
<diagnostics enableFor="AllHosts" />
<pipeline fakeExtensions=".ashx" />
<DiskCache dir="~/MyCachedImages" autoClean="false" hashModifiedDate="true" enabled="true" subfolders="32" cacheAccessTimeout="15000" asyncWrites="true" asyncBufferSize="10485760" />
<cleanupStrategy startupDelay="00:05" minDelay="00:00:20" maxDelay="00:05" optimalWorkSegmentLength="00:00:04" targetItemsPerFolder="400" maximumItemsPerFolder="1000" avoidRemovalIfCreatedWithin="24:00" avoidRemovalIfUsedWithin="4.00:00" prohibitRemovalIfUsedWithin="00:05" prohibitRemovalIfCreatedWithin="00:10" />
<plugins>
<add name="DiskCache" />
</plugins> </resizer>
Am I doing something wrong or Imageresizer doesnt support this scenario ? If not any good plugin to use disk based image cahce ?
Thanks in advance.

Answer 1

As I explained in the other public forums which you simultaneously posted this question, the ImageResizer supports dependency injection from the ground up. You're trying to wrap dependency injection with more dependency injection, but backwards.
A) ASP.NET MVC 3 and 4 prevent efficient disk caching, by design. You need to work with the ImageResizer HttpModule, not against it, to get good performance. That means using the URL API, not the Managed API wrapped by your own MVC ActionResults. Listen to my podcast with Scott Hanselman for more info.
B) SqlReader, S3Reader, MongoReader, VirtualFolder, and AzureReader all support dynamic injection, and can (with a tiny bit of configuration), all use the same path syntax. The ImageResizer is designed to allow easy migration between data stores.
C) You can use the Config.Current.Pipeline.Rewrite event to make the URL API use any syntax you want. This is much more flexible than MVC routes (and less buggy).
D) If you want to add another layer of dependency injection, implement IPlugin, and dynamically pick the appropriate data store and configure it from the Install method.