I have an app that has users whose profiles are accessible via site.com/username. When choosing a username, I make an AJAX call to a method in my UsersController to make sure the username is available (and check on the back end as well when submitted). I now want to add groups that will also be accessible through site.com/groupname. Since group and user names cannot collide, whatever controller method that responds to the AJAX call will need to check both so the check_username_available and check_groupname_available methods will do the exact same thing. What's the best practice / Rails way to handle this since I don't want to replicate code in both UsersController and GroupsController?
Having a method for each controller seems a bit redundant, even if the functionality is pulled out to a helper, since there will still be two routes that do the same thing. Having a separate controller solves the problem too but not sure this is good Rails practice.
code that is reused can be shared via a module
class UsersController < ActionController::Base
include NameUniqueness
end
class GroupsController < ActionController::Base
include NameUniqueness
end
module NameUniqueness
protected
def check_name
# implementation here
end
end
both controllers will now have access the check_name instance method.
DanPickett's answer is great.
Another choice is to make a class method in the user model and just call it from each controller. Since this name checking seems like a job for the model, that's what I would do.
class User
def self.check(stuff) ...
Related
I'm slightly new to Rails (i.e. stupid and need some teachin').
I have a controller (call it ControllerFoo) that performs a particular task (theMethod) which could be useful in other controllers (say, from within ControllerBar). So, of course, the method is defined as self.theMethod in ControllerFoo (which means it's a class method, right?), and access in ControllerBar as ControllerFoo.theMethod. Confused yet?
Here's the problem: the ControllerFoo.theMethod uses session data, and when called from ControllerBar, session is nil. In fact, it seems that session is also nil when being called from itself. I guess what I'm saying is class methods can't access session data?
<rant>I hate how session data can't simply be accessed anywhere like in PHP</rant>
So for now, since I'm not smart enough to know how to do this correctly, I've just duplicated the logic in several places throughout my app. But this is not DRY at all, and I hate it.
So how can I create a method in a controller that's accessible to other controllers and can also access session data?
class ControllerFoo < ApplicationController
def self.theMethod (greeting)
p "#{greeting} #{session[:user]}!"
end
end
class ControllerBar < ApplicationController
def show
ControllerFoo.theMethod("Hello,")
end
end
Couple of options...
Put the shared method in the shared parent ApplicationController
Create a module that both ControllerFoo and ControllerBar will include
e.g.
module SharedModule
def theMethod (greeting)
p "#{greeting} #{session[:user]}!"
end
end
class ControllerFoo < ApplicationController
include SharedModule
end
class ControllerBar < ApplicationController
include SharedModule
def show
theMethod("Hello,")
end
end
The way you would do this is Ruby would be to create a module containing the class (or instance) methods you wish to share and include it in the classes you need to have those methods defined in.
That title doesn't really explain everything so here goes. I have two Rails engines that share some functionality (ie. user model and authentication). I have a base User class and then two other User classes that inherit from this base class for each app like so:
class User; end
class App1::User < ::User; end
class App2::User < ::User; end
My authentication has a method similar to the following
def user_from_session
User.find_by_id(session[:user_id])
end
which is included in my application_controller. My problem here is that when a user is fetched... it always uses the base User class. What I really want is to be able to fetch a User that is the same type as the app calling that method.
For instance, if a user is on SomeController:
class App1::SomeController < ApplicationController; end
I want the method in the application_controller to pull out the App1 so that it instantiates an App1::User rather than just a User
Is this possible?
I'm NOT looking for a solution that involves two user_from_session methods, one for each application. I am aware of how to implement that. I'm more interested in know if this type of thing is possible in Ruby.
Though I'd caution you to find a better, less hacky way to do this, here's how you might do it:
def user_from_session
# App1::Whatever::FooController -> App1::Whatever
module_name = self.class.name.split('::')[0..-2].join('::')
# App1::Whatever -> App1::Whatever::User
user_class = "#{module_name}::User".constantize
# App1::Whatever::User.find_by_id(...)
user_class.find_by_id(session[:user_id])
end
I understand that we're supposed to avoid putting logic in the controller. So what is the proper way to implement things like user access controls. Let's suppose I have User, where each instance has a flag method admin? that determines whether the user can access information from other users.
Option 1: Put access controls in custom model
Model:
class User < ActiveRecord::Base
def self.get_list(accessor)
return [] unless accessor.admin?
self.all
end
end
Controller:
class UsersController < ApplicationController
def index
#users = User.get_list(current_user)
end
end
current_user would probably be defined somewhere in the application controller.
Option 2: Put access controls in the controller
Model:
class User < ActiveRecord::Base
end
Controller:
class UsersController < ApplicationController
def index
#users = current_user.admin? User.all : []
end
end
There are also some peripheral consequences such as where tests go and how they're implemented.
My instinct is that the first of the two options is preferable, but I've only ever used option 2 in the past. Also, it seems like the generally accepted (as far as I can tell) practice of putting on action-wide access filters is done at the controller level as in:
class UsersController < ApplicationController
before_filter :verify_logged_in
end
Any logic controlling routing of your application belongs in your controller. As for your example, the first is preferable but really there's not much in it.
It's easy for opinionated frameworks make us almost obsessive about doing things in a perceived correct way. In your example such a tiny amount of logic would, in my opinion, be perfectly fine to leave in your controller. If you were to abstract it, give it a descriptive name that described better what the method is doing otherwise you're simply making your code needlessly difficult to read.
As a rails rookie, the second option to me seems far easier to read and comphrehend. I prefer how I can read the single line in the controller and see exactly what you are doing.
In the first example, this logic is hidden someplace else (obviously the model, but I'm a rookie remember!) and seems slightly verbose (for this particular example).
I don't mean to suggest keeping it easier for new kids is A Good Thing, just pointing out a preference.
I am trying to access an instance variable which is set in the controller in the model. The controller is the products controller and the model is the products model. The instance variable is a instance of another model called account.
The instance variable is #current_account
When I run the code nothing happens, I do not get an error. Does anyone know where I can find something read about access instance variables set in the controller from the model?
Thanks
Eef
You shouldn't generally try to access the controller from the model for high-minded issues I won't go into.
I solved a similar problem like so:
class Account < ActiveRecord::Base
cattr_accessor :current
end
class ApplicationController < ActionController::Base
before_filter :set_current_account
def set_current_account
# set #current_account from session data here
Account.current = #current_account
end
end
Then just access the current account with Account.current
DISCLAIMER: The following code breaks MVC conventions, that said...
Using class attributes can probably lead to thread safety issues. I would use Thread.current + around_filter to store controller related data at thread level, and ensure it gets cleared
just before the request finishes:
class ApplicationController < ActionController::Base
around_filter :wrap_with_hack
def wrap_with_hack
# We could do this (greener solution):
# http://coderrr.wordpress.com/2008/04/10/lets-stop-polluting-the-threadcurrent-hash/
# ... but for simplicity sake:
Thread.current[:controller] = self
begin
yield
ensure
# Prevent cross request access if thread is reused later
Thread.current[:controller] = nil
end
end
end
Now the current controller instance will be avaliable globaly during the request processing through Thread.current[:controller]
If you need to access a controller variable from a model it generally means your design is wrong because a controller serves as bridge between view and model (at least in Rails), controller gets info from models, models shouldn't know anything about controllers, but if you want to do it anyway you can do it just as jeem said, but I'd rather do:
class << self
attr_accessor :current
end
instead of cattr_accessor :current
you can see why here => cattr_accessor doesn't work as it should
I can't comment directly so I'll post here: the accepted answer does not seem to be right. As #vise notes, class variables are shared across requests. So unless there's just one current account for the entire app, this won't behave as expected.
For more, see the accepted answer by #molf here: Is Rails shared-nothing or can separate requests access the same runtime variables?
I'm not sure if I understand the question exactly, but I'll take a stab.
I think if you need to access a controller instance variable from the model then you either need to make it an attribute in the model, or move your logic to the other class controller, not model.
I am in the middle of migrating my application from using subdirectories for userspace to subdomains (ie. domain.com/~user to user.domain.com). I've got a method in my user class currently to get the "home" URL for each user:
class User
def home_url
"~#{self.username}"
# How I'd like to do it for subdomains:
#"http://#{self.username}.#{SubdomainFu.host_without_subdomain(request.host)}"
end
end
I'd like to update this for subdomains, but without hardcoding the domain into the method. As you can see, I am using the subdomain-fu plugin, which provides some methods that I could use to do this, except that they need access to request, which is not available to the model.
I know it's considered bad form to make request available in a model, so I'd like to avoid doing that, but I'm not sure if there's a good way to do this. I could pass the domain along every time the model is initialized, I guess, but I don't think this is a good solution, because I'd have to remember to do so every time a class is initialized, which happens often.
The model shouldn't know about the request, you're right. I would do something like this:
# app/models/user.rb
class User
def home_url(domain)
"http://#{username}.#{domain}"
end
end
# app/controllers/application_controller.rb
class ApplicationController < ActionController::Base
# ...
def domain
SubdomainFu.host_without_subdomain(request.host)
end
# Make domain available to all views too
helper_method :domain
end
# where you need it (controller or view)
user.home_url(domain)
If there is such a thing as a canonical user home URL, I would make a configurable default domain (e.g. YourApp.domain) that you can use if you call User#home_url without arguments. This allows you to construct a home URL in places where, conceptually, the "current domain" does not exist.
While molf's answer is good, it did not solve my specific problem as there were some instances where other models needed to call User#home_url, and so there would be a lot of methods I'd have to update in order to pass along the domain.
Instead, I took inspiration from his last paragraph and added a base_domain variable to my app's config class, which is the set in a before_filter in ApplicationController:
module App
class << self
attr_accessor :base_domain
end
end
class ApplicationController < ActionController::Base
before_filter :set_base_domain
def set_base_domain
App.base_domain = SubdomainFu.host_without_subdomain(request.host)
end
end
And thus, when I need to get the domain in a model, I can just use App.base_domain.