I have several build files which all import the same base build file, like this:
base.xml:
<project name="base">
<!-- does not define a 'build' target -->
</project>
buildA.xml:
<project name="buildA">
<import file="base.xml" />
<target name="build">
<ant antfile="buildB.xml" target="build"
inheritall="false" inheritrefs="false" />
</target>
</project>
buildB.xml:
<project name="buildB">
<import file="base.xml" />
<target name="build">
...snip...
</target>
</project>
(Module A depends on module B.)
Now, the above calling of B's build target from buildA.xml gives the following error:
Duplicated project name in import. Project base defined first in buildA.xml and again in buildB.xml
Since both buildA.xml and buildB.xml inherit the same base.xml, this seems unavoidable.
How could I get rid of this error?
Based on sudocode's answer, I solved the problem. Because the absolute path to base.xml is different in both cases, Ant does not recognize it as the same file. Even though inheritAll is set to false, the context of the calling task is preserved and this causes the name clash.
To solve this, one can omit the name attribute from base.xml. Since Ant 1.8, the import task has an attribute as, which can be used to reference base targets when the base project is nameless. If you don't override any targets, you can use include instead of import. I'm on 1.7, so that does not help me.
For previous versions of Ant, you can go through an exec call to prevent proliferation of the Ant context entirely (then you get two running Ant instances). Better yet, find a way to import the exact same base.xml (with the same absolute path) in both files.
Are you using Ant 1.6? This resolved Ant bug looks like the same issue.
EDIT
I tried to reproduce the dir structure you refer to in your recent comment.
./base.xml
./buildA
./buildA/buildA.xml
./buildB
./buildB/buildB.xml
And amended the build files accordingly, e.g.
<project name="buildA">
<import file="../base.xml"/>
<target name="build">
<ant antfile="../buildB/buildB.xml" target="build" inheritall="false" inheritrefs="false"/>
</target>
</project>
I still get no build error for the following with ant 1.8.2 or 1.7.1:
ant -f buildA/buildA.xml build
Related
I'm having some trouble freeing component builds from JDeveloper Studio...
I have a reference to aia.jar set up in JDeveloper, which I can't seem to specify correctly on the Ant command line.
Here's my command line:
ant -f c:\...\jdeveloper\bin\ant-sca-package.xml
-D"compositeDir=c:/.../ProcessImpl"
-D"compositeName=ProcessImpl"
-D"revision=1.0"
-D"scac.application.home=c:/.../.adf"
Everything seems to go well at first, until it fails with: package oracle.apps.aia.core.eh.logging does not exist
Here is the solution, for the sake of anyone that has the same issue in future...
My aia.jar lived in jdeveloper/lib ...
I had tried the CLASS_PATH environment variable, the -lib <path> option on the ant command line, and even adding to the classpath property in ant-sca-compile.xml - none of which made any difference.
The aia.jar file apparently HAS to exist in the SCA-INF/lib subdirectory of the project being built. In the end I created a wrapper build.xml file that copies the required dependency to this location and then calls out to ant-sca-package.xml...
<target name="build">
<echo>Copy AIA.jar</echo>
<mkdir dir="${sca-inf.dir}/lib" />
<copy file="${aia.file}" todir="${sca-inf.dir}/lib"/>
<echo>Create Package</echo>
<ant antfile="${script.home}/ant-sca-package.xml" inheritAll="false" target="package">
<property name="compositeDir" value="${path}/${name}"/>
<property name="compositeName" value="${name}"/>
<property name="revision" value="${rev}"/>
<property name="sca.application.home" value="${adf.dir}"/>
<property name="scac.application.home" value="${adf.dir}"/>
</ant>
</target>
I have a shared ant script b.ant which internally use antcall. It calculates a property that the client scripts use. I use include instead of import client scripts to avoid unintentional overwriting of targets, but this gives me a problem with the antcall.
When using include all targets in b are prefixes, and depends attributes in b are updated accordingly. This is however not true for antcall. Is there a there are way to handle this, i.e. make antcall always call the "local" ant target?
I can workaround this by using import, but then I'll get all the overwrite problems. It is not possible to use depends instead of antcall.
Example files
I have two files:
a.ant
<project>
<include file="b.ant" as="b" />
<target name="test-depends" depends="b.depend">
<echo>${calculated-property}</echo>
</target>
<target name="test-call" depends="b.call">
<echo>${calculated-property}</echo>
</target>
</project>
b.ant
<project>
<target name="depend" depends="some-target">
<property name="calculated-property" value="Hello World"/>
</target>
<target name="call">
<antcall target="some-target" inheritrefs="true"/>
<property name="calculated-property" value="Hello World"/>
</target>
<target name="some-target"/>
</project>
Example output
Calling test-depend works as expected but test-call fails with this output:
b.call:
BUILD FAILED
D:\ws\rambo2\ws-dobshl\ant-test\b.ant:6: The following error occurred while executing this line:
Target "some-target" does not exist in the project "null".
Total time: 258 milliseconds
Ant is a dependency matrix specification language. Usually a bunch of <antcall/>, <ant/>, <include/> and <import/> is a sign of a poorly written build script. It's a developer trying to force Ant to act like a programming language.
For developer, it makes sense to break up a program into smaller files. Even Python and Perl scripts can benefit from this. However, breaking up an Ant build script usually causes problems. We had a developer who went through every project and broke up all the build.xml files into six or seven separate build files in order to improve the process. It basically broke the whole Ant dependency mechanism. To fix it, he then tossed in a bunch of <ant/> calls and <include> tasks. In the end, it meant that each target was called between 12 to 20 times.
Not using <import/> and <antcall/> isn't a hard and fast rule. But, I've been using Ant for years and rarely ever used these mechanisms. When I do, it's usually for a shared build file that multiple projects will use (which sounds like what you have) but instead of defining targets in my shared build file, I define macros. This eliminates the target namespace issues that you are having, and the macros work better because they act more like Ant tasks. This is especially true with the introduction of <local/> in Ant 1.8.
See if you can restructure the shared build file into using <macrodef/> instead of targets. It will make it much easier to include your shared build file.
Give a name to the <project> in b.ant and then change the target of the <antcall>:
<project name="b"> <!-- Give the project a name -->
<target name="depend" depends="some-target">
<property name="calculated-property" value="In b.depend"/>
</target>
<target name="call">
<!-- Specify the name of the project containing the target -->
<antcall target="b.some-target" inheritrefs="true"/>
<property name="calculated-property" value="In b.call"/>
</target>
<target name="some-target"/>
</project>
The result of ant -f a.ant test-call:
b.call:
b.some-target:
test-call:
[echo] In b.call
BUILD SUCCESSFUL
With the changes to b.ant, the <include> in a.ant can be simplified by removing the as attribute:
<include file="b.ant" />
We have a large amount of apps. They all have a build.xml file located in the projects base directory. I am trying to create an ant script that will go through and call a specific target on each of the build.xml files in all the projects.
Here are the issues:
Some of the projects are in deeper directories than others.
Only some of the projects need to be built at a time.
I was trying to use subant + antfile and defining a CSV of file paths in a properties file, but this did not work. Below is what i have and the error i am getting.
If there is a better way to do this or you know what my problem is, please let me know! Thanks!
This is the property defined in a property file. I am wanting the person running the script to add the file paths in here that are relative to the current location of the script they are running.
projects.to.build=
This is the subant task i am trying to use in the main build script.
<filelist
id="projectNames"
dir="${basedir}"
files="${projects.to.build}"
/>
<target name="debugAll" description="Builds all the projects listed in the projectNames.properties file.">
<subant target="debug" antfile="${projects.to.build}">
</subant>
</target>
Here is the error i get when i try to run the build script when there are projects defined in the properties file. I am using the relative path. For example: ..\Apps\AnApp1\build.xml,..\Apps\AnApp2\build.xml,..\OtherApps\foo\AnotherApp1\build.xml
"No Build Path Specified" (at my subant task)
You specified the antfile attribute, so ANT was expecting to a single build.xml file.
The subant documentation describes how you can use a fileset as child parameter.
Here's an example:
<project name="Subant demo" default="run-debug-target">
<target name="run-debug-target">
<subant target="debug">
<fileset dir="." includes="**/build.xml" excludes="build.xml"/>
</subant>
</target>
</project>
Update
Alternatively a filelist could be used:
<project name="Dry run" default="run">
<target name="run">
<subant target="test">
<filelist dir="projects" files="one/build.xml,two/build.xml,three/build.xml,four/build.xml"/>
</subant>
</target>
</project>
Processing the following build files:
projects/one/build.xml
projects/two/build.xml
projects/three/build.xml
projects/four/build.xml
Is it possible to run the target in the all the build files concurrently ?
E.g.
<project name="Dry run" default="run">
<target name="run">
<subant target="test">
<filelist dir="projects" files="one/build.xml,two/build.xml,three/build.xml,four/build.xml"/>
</subant>
</target>
</project>
In this example, is there any way to run target "test" present in all the build files (one/build.xml,two/build.xml,three/build.xml,four/build.xml) concurrently ?
I wanted to have a look which system properties are set here (and to which values), so the easiest way (if not writing a new Java program here) would be adding some lines to my ant build script:
<target name="properties">
<echoproperties/>
</target>
But running ant gives my this error message:
/u/ebermann/projektoj/stackoverflow-examples/build.xml:19: Problem: failed to create task or type echoproperties
Cause: the class org.apache.tools.ant.taskdefs.optional.EchoProperties was not found.
This looks like one of Ant's optional components.
Action: Check that the appropriate optional JAR exists in
-/usr/share/ant/lib
-/u/ebermann/.ant/lib
-a directory added on the command line with the -lib argument
Do not panic, this is a common problem.
The commonest cause is a missing JAR.
This is not a bug; it is a configuration problem
Okay, so I don't panic, but wonder what to do.
I have Ant 1.7.1 here (an OpenSUSE system), and sadly no documentation for this version, and I'm not root to install either a current ant version or the documentation for the old version (I just downloaded it and it still does not say which jar file is needed here). Of the directories listed above, only /usr/share/ant/lib exists, but it contains nothing like optional.
I would want to download the necessary jar file and put it in my home directory, but where to find it? The ant download archive contains nothing like that, and I have no idea where else to search. (I did google a bit, but did not find anything.
So, can someone give me some pointers where to find the right jar file?
(I suppose the solution is quite easy, and something is just blocking my view.)
After vahapt's answer, I downloaded the file from the apache repository, and put it into the directory /u/ebermann/.ant/lib mentioned by the error message. Running ant properties again - the same result as above.
$ jar -tf /u/ebermann/.ant/lib/ant-nodeps-1.7.1.jar | grep 'EchoProperties.class'
org/apache/tools/ant/taskdefs/optional/EchoProperties.class
This looks like it should work - is the error message simply wrong?
If I put it directly into the CLASSPATH, it works:
$ CLASSPATH=/u/ebermann/.ant/lib/ant-nodeps-1.7.1.jar ant properties
Buildfile: build.xml
properties:
[echoproperties] #Ant properties
[echoproperties] #Thu Mar 10 00:46:22 CET 2011
...
[echoproperties] user.name=ebermann
[echoproperties] user.timezone=
BUILD SUCCESSFUL
Total time: 0 seconds
I don't want to change my normal CLASSPATH variable, and it should work by putting it into this directory, or did I understand something wrong?
Any ideas, or is this an ant bug?
(Also, why is this file nowhere mentioned in the ant documentation?)
Edit:
After the answer from vahapt, my ant build-file looks like this:
<project name="stackoverflow-examples" basedir=".">
<target name="echoproperties.prepare">
<available property="echoproperties.works"
classname="org.apache.tools.ant.taskdefs.optional.EchoProperties"
/>
</target>
<target name="echoproperties.init"
depends="echoproperties.prepare"
unless="echoproperties.works">
<taskdef name="echoproperties" classname="org.apache.tools.ant.taskdefs.optional.EchoProperties">
<classpath>
<fileset dir="${user.home}/.ant/lib">
<include name="ant-nodeps.jar" />
</fileset>
</classpath>
</taskdef>
</target>
<target name="properties" depends="echoproperties.init">
<echoproperties/>
</target>
</project>
This re-registers the task only if it is not already in the ant classpath. (Thus it should also work for complete ant installations which do not have this file in the home directory).
I would still say that This is not a bug; it is a configuration problem is not totally right, even more as putting the file in the indicated directory does not help.
One more interesting observation: The nodeps.jar in ${user.home}/.ant/lib (i.e. now /u/ebermann/.ant/lib/ant-nodeps.jar) is already in the class path (the one shown by ${java.class.path}, but this seems not to help for <echoproperties> to work without this taskdef.
So, this works too:
<target name="echoproperties.init"
depends="echoproperties.prepare"
unless="echoproperties.works">
<taskdef name="echoproperties"
classname="org.apache.tools.ant.taskdefs.optional.EchoProperties"
classpath="${java.class.path}" />
</target>
When you make a google search, results point to ant-nodeps-1.7.1.jar
Make sure that jar exists and you've added it into the classpath
For the second part of your question:
SOLUTION 1. You do not need to modify your CLASSPATH variable. Instead you might add it by adding the parameter -cp [JAR FILE LOCATION] (-cp is for "java" executable)
SOLUTION 2. Jar files are simply zip files, open ant-nodeps.jar copy its content to ant.jar throw away ant-nodeps.jar
SOLUTION 3. See the sample below. taskdef is a ant feature that loads a jar or a class into ClassLoader hierarchy. (You load the class before using it, works like a charm)
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="ASCII"?>
<project name="Test" default="properties" basedir=".">
<target name="properties" depends="init">
<echoproperties/>
</target>
<target name="init">
<taskdef name="echoproperties" classname="org.apache.tools.ant.taskdefs.optional.EchoProperties">
<classpath>
<fileset dir="${ant.library.dir}">
<include name="ant-nodeps.jar" />
</fileset>
</classpath>
</taskdef>
</target>
</project>
I downloaded Ant 1.7.1 and looked in the documentation that came with it. There it described echoproperties as an optional task, but didn't mention where to get the jarfile for this optional task.
Looking inside the lib folder, I discovered the ant-nodeps.jar. Apparently, it was included with Ant 1.7.1.
I would recommend that you download and install Ant 1.8. Since Ant is a Java jar file, it's not really all that difficult to install the latest and greatest version.
I looked on my Mac, and /usr/bin/ant is a link to /usr/share/ant/bin and /usr/share/ant/ is a link to /usr/share/java/ant-1.8.2. So, all I have to do is point /usr/share/ant/bin/ to the correct version of Ant.
In Ant 1.8.2, echoproperties is now a standard task.
Is there a well-established way to share Ant targets between projects? I have a solution currently, but it's a bit inelegant. Here's what I'm doing so far.
I've got a file called ivy-tasks.xml hosted on a server on our network. This file contains, among other targets, boilerplate tasks for managing project dependencies with Ivy. For example:
<project name="ant-ivy-tasks" default="init-ivy"
xmlns:ivy="antlib:org.apache.ivy.ant">
...
<target name="ivy-download" unless="skip.ivy.download">
<mkdir dir="${ivy.jar.dir}"/>
<echo message="Installing ivy..."/>
<get src="http://repo1.maven.org/maven2/org/apache/ivy/ivy/${ivy.install.version}/ivy-${ivy.install.version}.jar"
dest="${ivy.jar.file}" usetimestamp="true"/>
</target>
<target name="ivy-init" depends="ivy-download"
description="-> Defines ivy tasks and loads global settings">
<path id="ivy.lib.path">
<fileset dir="${ivy.jar.dir}" includes="*.jar"/>
</path>
<taskdef resource="org/apache/ivy/ant/antlib.xml"
uri="antlib:org.apache.ivy.ant"
classpathref="ivy.lib.path"/>
<ivy:settings url="http://myserver/ivy/settings/ivysettings-user.xml"/>
</target>
...
</project>
The reason this file is hosted is because I don't want to:
Check the file into every project that needs it - this will result in duplication, making maintaining the targets harder.
Have my build.xml depend on checking out a project from source control - this will make the build have more XML at the top-level just to access the file.
What I do with this file in my projects' build.xmls is along the lines of:
<property name="download.dir" location="download"/>
<mkdir dir="${download.dir}"/>
<echo message="Downloading import files to ${download.dir}"/>
<get src="http://myserver/ivy/ivy-tasks.xml" dest="${download.dir}/ivy-tasks.xml" usetimestamp="true"/>
<import file="${download.dir}/ivy-tasks.xml"/>
The "dirty" part about this is that I have to do the above steps outside of a target, because the import task must be at the top-level. Plus, I still have to include this XML in all of the build.xml files that need it (i.e. there's still some amount of duplication).
On top of that, there might be additional situations where I might have common (non-Ivy) tasks that I'd like imported. If I were to provide these tasks using Ivy's dependency management I'd still have problems, since by the time I'd have resolved the dependencies I would have to be inside of a target in my build.xml, and unable to import (due to the constraint mentioned above).
Is there a better solution for what I'm trying to accomplish?
If you are using ANT 1.8+, then you could just import the build.xml directly from the hosted location.
http://ant.apache.org/manual/Tasks/import.html
Since Ant 1.8.0 the task can also
import resources from URLs or
classpath resources (which are URLs,
really). If you need to know whether
the current build file's source has
been a file or an URL you can consult
the property ant.file.type.projectname
(using the same example as above
ant.file.type.builddocs) which either
have the value "file" or "url".
<!-- importing.xml -->
<project name="importing" basedir="." default="...">
<import file="http://myserver/ivy/ivy-tasks.xml"/>
</project>
If you use Antlibs you can package them all inside a JAR file. Then simply copy this file into the ${ANT_HOME}/lib directory to use them.
After some additional searching, a possible solution would be to use SVN externals to check out specific required files that may be needed by the build.xml.
However, this would only work for users who are using Subversion as source control. It would still be nice to have a SCM-agnostic solution for users who aren't using Subversion, or another SCM that supports similar functionality.
What we've done is to create a project called 'bootstrap' which contains the various xml-files needed for the other projects at our office.
So to set up your development environment you run build.xml in bootstrap which copies the xml-files (like your ivy-stuff, and other targets) to a known location, and then your build files include these like this:
<import file="${ant.bootstrap.dir}/ant-commons.xml" />
<import file="${ant.bootstrap.dir}/ant-commons-ear.xml" />
Our bootstrap build.xml contains this:
<target name="install">
<fail unless="ant.bootstrap.dir" message="ant.bootstrap.dir ${missing.property.message}"/>
<copy todir = "${ant.bootstrap.dir}">
<fileset dir = "src/xml"/>
</copy>
</target>