FsCheck lazy generators - f#

Question

I have issues with generation of data within my tests.
testProperty "calculate Operation against different operations should increase major" <| fun operationIdApi operationIdClient summaryApi summaryClient descriptionApi descriptionClient ->
( notAllEqual [
fun () -> assessEquality <| StringEquals(operationIdApi, operationIdClient)
fun () -> assessEquality <| StringEquals(summaryApi , summaryClient)
fun () -> assessEquality <| StringEquals(descriptionApi, descriptionClient)
]) ==> lazy (
let operationClient = createOpenApiOperation operationIdClient summaryClient descriptionClient
let operationAPI = createOpenApiOperation operationIdApi summaryApi descriptionApi
let actual = calculate operationAPI operationClient
Expect.equal actual (Fact.Semver.IncreaseMajor) "return IncreaseMajor"
)
The code that is actually tested is :
semver {
if operationAPI.OperationId<> operationClient.OperationId then yield! IncreaseMajor
if operationAPI.Summary <> operationClient.Summary then yield! IncreaseMajor
}
The test should fail when the data produced is same OperationId, same summary and different description.
But it does not and it led me to create my own generator or at least try to do so:
I wanted my test to be written like this :
testProperty "calculate Operation against different operations should increase major" <| fun (operationId:ElementSet<string>) (summary:ElementSet<string>) ->
Therefore I create a type accordingly:
type ElementSet<'a> =
| Same of 'a
| Different
and a generator for this type :
let setGen<'a> =
Gen.oneof [
gen {
let! v = Arb.generate<'a>
return Same(v)
}
gen { return Different}
]
type ElementSetGenerator =
static member ElementSet() =
Arb.fromGen setGen<'a>
do Arb.register<ElementSetGenerator>() |> ignore
I was then trying to extract the data to construct my object :
let createOpenApiOperation operationId summary=
let pi = OpenApiOperation(OperationId=operationId.Get, Summary=summary.Get)
pi
The Get method did not exist yet so I was about to implement it by adding a member to my ElementSet<'a>:
type ElementSet<'a> =
| Same of 'a
| Different
with member this.Get =
match this with
| Same s -> s
| Different -> Arb.generate<'a>// some random generation here
And this is where I am stuck. I would love to get some randomness here when I extract data. I wonder if this is the correct way to do so, or if I should have answered the problem earlier?
Thanks for your inputs.

Answer 1

I think I found it, the answer was to handle it at the beginning :
let setGen<'a when 'a:equality> =
Gen.oneof [
gen {
let! v = Arb.generate<'a>
return Same(v)
}
gen {
let! x,y =
Arb.generate<'a>
|> Gen.two
|> Gen.filter (fun (a,b)-> a <> b)
return Different(x,y)
}
]
and then to use two getter to access the values :
type ElementSet<'a> when 'a:equality=
| Same of 'a
| Different of 'a*'a
with member this.Fst = match this with | Same s -> s | Different (a, b)-> a
member this.Snd = match this with | Same s -> s | Different (a, b)-> b
this way I can access values within my test:
testProperty "calculate Operation against different operations should increase major" <| fun (operationId:ElementSet<NonWhiteSpaceString>) (summary:ElementSet<NonWhiteSpaceString>) (description:ElementSet<NonWhiteSpaceString>) ->
let operationClient = createOpenApiOperation operationId.Fst summary.Fst description.Fst
let operationAPI = createOpenApiOperation operationId.Snd summary.Snd description.Snd
let actual = calculate operationAPI operationClient
Expect.equal actual (Fact.Semver.IncreaseMajor) "return IncreaseMajor"
for the record I then have the creation of my stub as follows :
let createOpenApiOperation (operationId:NonWhiteSpaceString) (summary:NonWhiteSpaceString) (description:NonWhiteSpaceString)=
let pi = OpenApiOperation(OperationId=operationId.Get, Summary=summary.Get, Description=description.Get)
pi