Field of view of a GoPro camera - opencv

Question

I have calibrated my GoPro Hero 4 Black using Camera calibration toolbox for Matlab and calculated its fields of view and focal length using OpenCV's calibrationMatrixValues(). These, however, differ from GoPro's specifications. Istead of 118.2/69.5 FOVs I get 95.4/63.4 and focal length 2.8mm instead of 17.2mm. Obviously something is wrong.
I suppose the calibration itself is correct since image undistortion seems to be working well.
Can anyone please give me a hint where I made a mistake? I am posting my code below.
Thanks.
Code
cameraMatrix = new Mat(3, 3, 6);
for (int i = 0; i < cameraMatrix.height(); i ++)
for (int j = 0; j < cameraMatrix.width(); j ++) {
cameraMatrix.put(i, j, 0);
}
cameraMatrix.put(0, 0, 582.18394);
cameraMatrix.put(0, 2, 663.50655);
cameraMatrix.put(1, 1, 582.52915);
cameraMatrix.put(1, 2, 378.74541);
cameraMatrix.put(2, 2, 1.);
org.opencv.core.Size size = new org.opencv.core.Size(1280, 720);
//output parameters
double [] fovx = new double[1];
double [] fovy = new double[1];
double [] focLen = new double[1];
double [] aspectRatio = new double[1];
Point ppov = new Point(0, 0);
org.opencv.calib3d.Calib3d.calibrationMatrixValues(cameraMatrix, size,
6.17, 4.55, fovx, fovy, focLen, ppov, aspectRatio);
System.out.println("FoVx: " + fovx[0]);
System.out.println("FoVy: " + fovy[0]);
System.out.println("Focal length: " + focLen[0]);
System.out.println("Principal point of view; x: " + ppov.x + ", y: " + ppov.y);
System.out.println("Aspect ratio: " + aspectRatio[0]);
Results
FoVx: 95.41677635378488
FoVy: 63.43170132212425
Focal length: 2.8063085232812504
Principal point of view; x: 3.198308916796875, y: 2.3934605770833333
Aspect ratio: 1.0005929569269807
GoPro specifications
https://gopro.com/help/articles/Question_Answer/HERO4-Field-of-View-FOV-Information
Edit
Matlab calibration results
Focal Length: fc = [ 582.18394 582.52915 ] ± [ 0.77471 0.78080 ]
Principal point: cc = [ 663.50655 378.74541 ] ± [ 1.40781 1.13965 ]
Skew: alpha_c = [ -0.00028 ] ± [ 0.00056 ] => angle of pixel axes = 90.01599 ± 0.03208 degrees
Distortion: kc = [ -0.25722 0.09022 -0.00060 0.00009 -0.01662 ] ± [ 0.00228 0.00276 0.00020 0.00018 0.00098 ]
Pixel error: err = [ 0.30001 0.28188 ]
One of the images used for calibration
And the undistorted image

Answer 1

You have entered 6.17mm and 4.55mm for the sensor size in OpenCV, which corresponds to an aspect ratio 1.36 whereas as your resolution (1270x720) is 1.76 (approximately 16x9 format).
Did you crop your image before MATLAB calibration?
The pixel size seems to be 1.55µm from this Gopro page (this is by the way astonishingly small!). If pixels are squared, and they should be on this type of commercial cameras, that means your inputs are not coherent. Computed sensor size should be :
[Sensor width, Sensor height] = [1280, 720]*1.55*10^-3 = [1.97, 1.12]
mm
Even if considering the maximal video resolution which is 3840 x 2160, we obtain [5.95, 3.35]mm, still different from your input.
Please see this explanation about equivalent focal length to understand why the actual focal length of the camera is not 17.2 but 17.2*5.95/36 ~ 2.8mm. In that case, compute FOV using the formulas here for instance. You will indeed find values of 93.5°/61.7° (close to your outputs but still not what is written in the specifications because there probably some optical distortion due to the wide angles).
What I do not understand though, is how the focal distance returned can be right whereas sensor size entered is wrong. Could you give more info and/or send an image?
Edits after question updates
On that cameras, with a working resolution of 1280x720, the image is downsampled but not cropped so what I said above about sensor dimensions does not apply. The sensor size to consider is indeed the one used (6.17x4.55) as explained in your first comment.
The FOV is constrained by the calibration matrix inputs (fx, fy, cx, cy) given in pixels and the resolution. You can check it by typing:
2*DEGRES(ATAN(1280/(2*582.18394))) (=95.416776...°)
This FOV value is smaller than what is expected, but by the look of the undistorted image, your MATLAB distortion model is right and the calibration is correct. The barrel distortion due to the wide angle seems well corrected by the the rewarp you applied.
However, MATLAB toolbox uses a pinhole model, which is linear and cannot account for intrinsic parameters such as lens distortion. I assume this from the page :
https://fr.mathworks.com/help/vision/ug/camera-calibration.html
Hence, my best guess is that unless you find a model which fits more accurately the Gopro camera (maybe a wide-angle lens model), MATLAB calibration will return an intrinsic camera matrix corresponding to the "linear" undistorted image and the FOV will indeed be smaller (in the case of barrel distortion). You will have to apply distortion coefficients associated to the calibration to retrieve the actual FOV value.
We can see in the corrected image that side parts of the FOV get rejected out of bounds. If you had warped the image entirely, you would find that some undistorted pixels coordinates exceed [-1280/2;+1280/2] (horizontally, and idem vertically). Then, replacing opencv.core.Size(1280, 720) by the most extreme ranges obtained, you would hopefully retrieve Gopro website values.
In conclusion, I think you can rely on the focal distance value that you obtained if you make measurements in the center of your image, otherwise there is too much distortion and it doesn't apply.