We're working on an enterprise app that sends form data entered by the user to the server. The app attempts to send the data immediately after the user taps Save. If there is a problem sending the data (e.g. no network connection), we want to try again X minutes later, and periodically retry until the data is successfully sent. The requests are typically not very large or long-running, but the user is frequently in environments without network access, so retries are important.
It's simple enough to retry API requests when the app is running, but ideally we want to keep periodically retrying when the app is in the background. What is the best that we can achieve with iOS background execution features? Here are some options I see:
Use beginBackgroundTaskWithExpirationHandler: to make a one-time request for additional time. This would give us basically one additional attempt to send the data after the app goes to the background, but not repeated attempts
Use the "background fetch" feature, and attempt to send any new data to the server when the app is woken for background fetching. Sounds good in theory, but I'm concerned this may be an abuse of the background fetch feature?
Is one of these my best option? Is there another approach I'm missing?
This is a Xamarin app with iOS and Android implementations, though I don't think that has a significant impact on my question; I can write iOS specific code as needed.
I think there is one approach that you missed : background NSURLSessions. And I think this is what you should use.
I don't really know how many shots you can have with this. Here is what I recommend :
Begin a background task as well (with beginBackgroundTaskWithExpirationHandler:) when you start your background download.
As long as your background task hasn't expired, you will be able to restart the download, even if in the background.
If and when your background task expiration handler is called you need to end the background task immediately. At this point your app will stop executing and your download will continue in an external process.
When the download completes or fails, your app will be restarted in the background and given a chance to handle the result. The thing I don't know is if you will be able to start a new background download at this moment. You should just try or wait for someone that knows better than me...
Also be sure to check the -(void)URLSession:(NSURLSession *)session downloadTask:(NSURLSessionDownloadTask *)downloadTask didResumeAtOffset:(int64_t)fileOffset expectedTotalBytes:(int64_t)expectedTotalBytes; delegate method in order to restart your download where it failed and not start over.
Related
I've spent a lot of time looking at the options but am still not 100% clear, so wanted to reach out for some guidance.
Scenario is this:
User submits an HTTPS request to our backend server for some data via an iOS app
Depending on the data, the first (only) request can take a REALLY long time. like, say, 10+ minutes (shocking i know)
When that payload finally does become available and is returned via the HTTPS request, we then want to use it to update the UI in background.
The assumption here is that the user has moved on to another app whilst waiting for the data to arrive (and lets also assume they haven't killed the app).
Is it possible to handle this via iOS 8+ API's without the app being force/killed by Apple when in the background ?
Could we use background task for example?
var backgroundTask: UIBackgroundTaskIdentifier
xxx.beginBackgroundTaskWithName...
etc
Before testing some code blocks we just wanted to see if someone has (a) already done this and/or (b) whether we're heading in the right direction
Thanks for your help.
You should re-think on your web service which may take almost 10 min to process. If you are not able to optimize server task processing time then below one of the idea may be help you.
You can divided your one request into multiple request to reduce processing time and get response in faster way.
Your server should sent notification to app when its done with its task. So app will came to know task is done.
I am not sure why you try to update UI when apps in background mode , you may try to update UI when users come to foreground mode from background mode.
Please check this link which show as example of long running task. Where its use a blank audio play to keep alive app background task.
You can used "Background fetch" functionality.
For learning purpose you can refer this link
HKObserverQuery has the following method that supports receiving updates in the background:
- initWithSampleType:predicate:updateHandler:
The updateHandler has a completionHandler which has the following documentation:
This block is passed to the update handler. You must call this block
as soon as you are done processing the incoming data. Calling this
block tells HealthKit that you have successfully received the
background data. If you do not call this block, HealthKit continues to
attempt to launch your app using a backoff algorithm. If your app
fails to respond three times, HealthKit assumes that your app cannot
receive data, and stops sending you background updates.
From looking at other posts it seems like there's a lot of confusion revolving around this handler. Below are some questions that I have about it:
When should the handler be called? If called too late, then HK might think that the app never received the query update causing you to hit the background update 3-strikes back-off algorithm. The documentation states that it should be called after handling other queries. Depending on how long it would take to run those queries, it sounds like you could get dangerously close to hitting the background update strikes.
Why is this needed? Shouldn't the system know that the app has been launched and has received the background update? When using CoreBluetooth in the background it just wakes your app up in the background for 10 seconds. No need to call any handler or deal with the background update 3-strikes.
If you hit the background update 3-strikes and HK stops sending updates is that permanent? Does HK ever start sending the background updates again? What if there's a bug that prevented the handler to be called and now you've fixed it. Is the app stuck never receiving the updates? Or will it reset when the app is re-launched or updated?
Does HK keep your app running in the background until the handler is called? Is that part of its purpose or just a side effect? If it's part of its purpose how long can we run before needing to stop (and hit the first background update strike)?
When should the handler be called?
Call it after you are done your job. Your code should not do complex operations. The app is in the background and the user does not see what's changed. You can just set a "flag" that data is updated and do complex operations after the user launched the app. If your decision about either notifies the user or not based on complex operations, then try to refactor code so that all necessary data is pre-calculated (e.g. in UserDefaults) and extra data is simply fetched with that data. So, 1-2 seconds is enough for your calculation.
Why is this needed?
All such handlers have completion closures. They are needed for iOS to know if your app works fine. If your app will eat too much CPU time, then iOS could become slow. Hence, Apple wants to be sure that iOS works fine despite bad apps.
If you hit the background update 3-strikes and HK stops sending updates is that permanent?
No.
Does HK ever start sending the background updates again?
Yes. But it depends on many factors. It may try to call your app again in 1-2 days. If nothing changes it will call it rarely.
Does HK keep your app running in the background until the handler is called?
This is unknown. It depends on many factors. Probably if iPhone is charging it will allow running your app longer just to estimate if the completion handle is called or not. If your iPhone is not charging and closed to 0% battery, then more likely iOS will kill your app. So, you should not do any job after you called the completion handler. And try to keep it simple.
Recommendations
You should process new data as quickly as possible. If you need to fetch a lot of data, then try to optimize this and pre-calculate it when the app is in foreground, then save somewhere (UserDefault), and use new data with cached data to make a decision (e.g. notify user about something; I believe you need background updates exactly for that).
1-2 seconds or less is a good time for background updates.
I'm writing a iOS/Swift application which reads data from a REST service each X minutes and updates the UI accordingly.
Now I would like that when the app is put in the background, a task keeps being invoked at X minutes intervals reading from the REST service and, in case the data just read satisfies a given condition, show a notification prompting the user to bring the app back to the foreground.
In my searches I've read that during applicationDidEnterBackground event, I should start a task with beginBackgroundTaskWithExpirationHandler.
The problem is that, if I've understood correctly, this allows a maximum of 10/15 minutes after which the app is terminated if the task is not stopped with endBackgroundUpdateTask, while I want the task to keep polling the service indefinitely (at least until the user disable it from the app's settings)
My question is:
How is this kind of functionality performed normally? Do some common solutions or best practices exist for the solution of such a problem?
Use iOS Background Fetch feature where you can specify minimum background fetch interval. But actual interval between successive invocation of your code will be determined by iOS framework. For details checkout this link: http://code.tutsplus.com/tutorials/ios-7-sdk-working-with-background-fetch--mobile-20520
I use this approach in my app and I think it is a preferred way of doing.
You can use a local notification that can be presented from the background in case your condition is met.
Correct, iOS will eventually shut down the background process, you can't enforce continuous background activity. Use the backgroundTimeRemaining property to check how much time your application has left and try to handle it as gracefully as possible by calling endBackgroundTask so that iOS does not force kill your app.
As a solution, you could think about using remote notifications with with content-available : YES, which runs the didReceiveRemoteNotification
Have a look at the Parse.com Their local datastore is an abstraction for what you are trying to acheive.
By the way, is it really necessary to refresh in the background. If call is relatively quick, there is no need to refresh until the user open's the app. Background processes like that, using the net can be quite battery consuming when the user are not on a Wifi. So consider the use case carefully!
After reading the Apple documentation about the background download with the new iOS7 api (NSURLSession), I'm a bit disappointed. I was sure that Apple was managing the pause/resume over the network availability in the background (or provide an option to do so) but no…
So reading the documentation, this is what we've got:
https://developer.apple.com/library/ios/documentation/cocoa/Conceptual/URLLoadingSystem/NSURLSessionConcepts/NSURLSessionConcepts.html
When any task completes, the NSURLSession object calls the
delegate’s URLSession:task:didCompleteWithError: method with either an
error object, or nil if the task completed successfully.
If the task is a resumable download task, the NSError object’s userInfo dictionary
contains a value for the NSURLSessionDownloadTaskResumeData key. Your
app should use reachability APIs to determine when to retry, and
should then call downloadTaskWithResumeData: or
downloadTaskWithResumeData:completionHandler: to create a new download
task to continue that download. Go to step 3 (creating and resuming
task objects).
So far I understand the solution, but my question is: What architecture is the best to handle the loss of the network and resume downloading in the background?
On my side I'm using reachability and each time the network is available, I resume all tasks (referenced over a NSArray when creating), and suspends them when network is lost. This works well in foreground but for the background I need help on the following points:
If my app has no connectivity in foreground, if I go to the background without connectivity all my tasks remains suspended and won't came back if network is available…
Losing network in background, stop all my downloads/tasks.
Scenario:
In foreground, I start downloading my tasks
I go to background and after 10s switch to "aireplan mode"
All my tasks got an error. So in the method URLSession:task:didCompleteWithError: I resume them using
downloadTaskWithResumeData or if I can't (because some have not
enough resume data) I'm creating a new task without resume-ing it (except if network is back at that time).
Then I put the wifi up
As I'm still in background I cannot trigger a "resume" when network is back without launching the application…
How do I address these points? Have I missed something?
As I'm still in background I cannot trigger a "resume" when network is back without launching the application…
you can use "background fetch"，when the app is launched by fetch，then you can check network and resume the download task.
You should create the NSURLSession with background configurations, then your task is sent to a background demon and your app get called when it is completed.
Implementing:
application:handleEventsForBackgroundURLSession:completionHandler:
in the app delegate - without calling the completionHandler - causes the app to hang around in the background after the device loses its connection whilst suspended. That way, the app can still listen to reachability notifications and restart the download when a network connection becomes available once again. However, this is a pretty dodgy approach and may not pass Apple's app store submission guidelines. Additionally, this approach isn't much help when the connection is lost while the app is in the foreground and the connection regained whilst the app is suspended.
In the end I did the following:
Made use of the application:handleEventsForBackgroundURLSession:completionHandler: notification to pause my downloads in the background.
Made use of the intermittent background fetch notification (ie. application:performFetchWithCompletionHandler:completionHandler) to check connection status and restart any paused downloads. (hat-tip #gugupluto)
This still doesn't provide optimal download performance and may lead users to wonder why their "background download" hasn't finished once they reopen the app, but it seems to be the best we can hope for from Apple for now.
I have made an application which uploads a bunch of photos to a web server. It does so by repeated html calls, using multiple AFNetworking's AFHTPRequestOperation inside an operation queue. Right now, of the user exits the application, the queue stops. However, I want to continue the uploading queue until it's done, and then let the application go to sleep like it normally does.
I know that iOS provides a background expiration handler using "beginBackgroundTaskWithExpirationHandler" . I also know that AFURLConnectionOperation which is superclass of every HTTP operation class in AFNetworking can use that using
- (void)setShouldExecuteAsBackgroundTaskWithExpirationHandler:(void (^)(void))handler
But is there any way of making this work with an operation queue? Will setting the expiration handler of each operation do the job properly if I want to upload, let's say 10 photos?
I would appreciate any comments on background tasks with AFNetworking, or if anyone has experienced the same problem as me.
When an app goes to background, the OS will decide whether or not to completely stop your app or give it some time to complete what it's doing. In case it wants your app to stop, the expiration handler is called. If that's happening you should suspend all your tasks as fast as possible and prepare for a complete kill of the app, because that is what will happen a very short time after (5 seconds max). Take a look here.