net mvc 5 application using entity frame work etc and am new to .net c# etc (used to php & sessions)
so i have read allot about using .nets authentication service and that is some how registers a user upon login using FormsAuthentication.SetAuthCookie.
however i need to authenticate a user group for example admin or moderator. and from what i understand this can be achieved and be set using [authenticate(roles="admin")].
but surely if this is using a set cookie a user if they knew how could just change their registered role from user to admin to access restricted content?
so in as simple terms as possible how does .net mvc ensure security in authenticating users? can i use sessions instead of cookies? do i need to create my own authentication system.?
i have searched and read all i can find and most resources just explain how cookies work or how to implement authentication using cookies but very little about sessions.
I'll try to be as concise as possible:
Yes, ASP.NET MVC 5 uses cookies out of the box (if you chose Individual User Accounts in the project wizard)
The authorization of a group or role by means of an [Authorize(Roles="bla")] attribute to decorate controllers and/or controller methods will do just that. It's as if you would be writing
if(!User.IsInRole("bla"))
{
return new HttpUnauthorizedResult();
}
else
{
//here's your ultra-secret View
return View();
}
What if a user changes role while in-session or if he or she has a persistent cookie?
Indeed, you'll need to handle the interval between role change and cookie update.
Read up on it here
Long story short: the design decision is yours whether you think it better to log off a user when re-assigning roles or to make db roundtrips at every authorization check.
Can you use a session variable like in PHP? Sure (the Session object exists), but you shouldn't.
If and when the situation arises where you absolutely NEED to pass some arbitrary data however, there's ViewBag, ViewData and TempData.
I won't go as far as to say, that these constructs are superfluous, they certainly have their use from time to time, but do try and design your application to maximize the use of strongly-typed models, viewmodels and make use of the REST-based url architecture to get or put your data.
Related
I need to store the user ID, his company ID and name, in a way I won't have to query the database on every postback.
I know I have options like: ViewData, TempData or auth cookie, but, are there any better solution?
Best regards,
Juliano Nunes
This sounds like a classic use of Session.
ASP.NET session state enables you to store and retrieve values for a user as the user navigates ASP.NET pages in a Web application. HTTP is a stateless protocol. This means that a Web server treats each HTTP request for a page as an independent request. The server retains no knowledge of variable values that were used during previous requests. ASP.NET session state identifies requests from the same browser during a limited time window as a session, and provides a way to persist variable values for the duration of that session. By default, ASP.NET session state is enabled for all ASP.NET applications.
ASP.NET Profile Providers mechanism looks like a thing you're looking for - especially if you're already using Membership/Role providers.
More generic article on Profile properties: MSDN
I want to allow a new login to 'kick' a prior login session by the same account, in ASP.NET MVC.
It seems pretty clear that I'll give each browser a cooking representing the session ID. I'll track the currently active session ID in a server-side cache. If an already-active user attempts to log in, I'll verify the business logic (username, password, has been at least 15 minutes since last activity), and then update the active session ID cached at the server.
Now my issue is, a browser is holding an invalid session ID. What is the best point for me to inject a rejection or redirect to sign-in for this scenario?
I could modify the AuthorizeAttribute, but it seems like there should be a cleaner place to do this that won't require me to search and replace all my Authorize attributes, for example via a Global.asax event, or a controller event (I've already extended Controller in my project).
For example, if PreAuthorize existed, I would write some code there to test the request's cookies for a valid user/session ID pair, and if it didn't exist, I could simply remove the authentication cookie from the request, which would result in a standard unauthorized redirection.
So after a bit of research, it seems that a custom AuthorizeAttribute would typically be the correct approach. However, in my case, since I already had a custom role provider implemented, it was just a line of code to do it there. This also benefited me because I only wanted session concurrency for a single role. A side effect is that any use of web.config to control access to static files by role is also in-effect for session concurrency.
I need to create a website with non standard authorizaion logic (or rather not exactly the site. It should be separate Area in existing ASP.NET MVC3 application). Access to most of the pages sould be available only to authorized users. Authorization is carried out on the token passed in the link. After the user arrived to this area, the token should be checked and if it’s valid site will create a session key for 30 minutes (we already have our own mechanisms of session managment and it should be used).
Workflow example :
Third-party website generates a link for user, e.g. https://example.com/securedPage/?accountId=123456&token=XXXXX
Our site check this token (it depends on the page from URL, in this case https://example.com/securedPage/)
If the token is valid, example.com obtains a session key for the user and stores it in cookies.
Then user continues browsing whole website and only session is checked.
I’m new to MVC framework, so I’d like to ask several questions about architecture.
What is an apropriate place for this logic? ActionInvoker, Global.asax etc.?
Currently I'm trying to create my own ActionInvoker and keep this logic there, but I'm afraid that it could be a wrong way.
If I understand correctly you want yo extend the Action of the controller to inject/check your token.
I think the global action filters should help you.
I'm working on a project where certain logged in users have a dedicated page which they can choose the url of. When a user logins in i would like to display a link "View my page". I was just wondering what is the best way to store this baring in mind it needs to be accessible for as long as the user is logged in (The site has a remember me feature as well). Would a session variable surfice? or a cookie? Or a custom IPrincipal?
Many thanks
Matt
UPDATE:
What do you guys thing of using the UserData string you can store with the authentication cookie? It seems to satisfy my requirements, but i can't say I know a lot about it.
Forms authentication (based on cookie) should be enough. Here you can read about using FormsAuthentication with custom IPrincipal:
ASP.NET 2.0 Forms authentication - Keeping it customized yet simple
This page is about how forms authentication works:
Explained: Forms Authentication in ASP.NET 2.0
When you use forms authentication, you have Authorize attribute to limit access to controllers and action. It works pretty well. Your own IPrincipal is not necessary. I wouldn't use Session, because it can be easily lost.
Thanks guys, however I have ended up using the UserData string that you can store along with the authentication cookie. This way I know the data will always be available while the user is authenticated. And since I only need to remember simple data (the users url), this seems like a good solution.
Anybody with the same problem can find more info here:
http://www.asp.net/learn/security/tutorial-03-cs.aspx (See step 4)
If what you mean is that you want to display a different custom URL for each user and you simply want to cache that URL then there's a few things to consider:
If you use a session value or a cookie then you need code for the possibility of the value not being present. Both the server session or the browser session could expire and the user could still be logged in.
If you use a cookie you could consider setting the cookie expiry to the same as the authentication cookie expiry but this still doesn't guarantee availability.
A cookie value will not be secure, it could be modified. A session value will be secure.
If you're using custom forms authentication then you could store the URL in the authentication cookie itself and then load it into a custom IPrincipal. I would advise against that as I don't feel it's the right place.
If you're just trying to cache the URL then as long as your code re-fetches the data when the value is not present then a session value or a cookie will be fine depending on the level of security required.
If I have read that wrong and you just want to show/hide a link to depending on whether a user is authorized or not you can simple use
<% if (User.Identity.IsAuthenticated) { %>
view my page
<% } %>
And have your MyPage action in your controller render the dedicated page for the user.
I'm working through a previous webforms application to convert it to MVC and have one big issue that I can't seem to find any good resources about. I want the ability to capture the identity of the user (windows auth set in the web.config) but in the global.asax I can't seem to get access to session (but I can get the identity information). Or when I'm working inside a base class for my controllers, I don't have access to the httpContext in the constructor (but I do have access to session)
Anyone have a good solution for this issue? Previously in webforms I had a master page that did some verification and set some session vars depending on your id/etc
You can always get access to the session, or any other httpContext based entity, so long as they have already been instantiated, by using this line of code
HttpContext.Current.Session
HttpContext.Current.Request
HttpContext.Current.Server
...etc
But also, you should always have access to the User & Identity information without needing to persist it to the session unless you are making modifications to the Identity and storing those modifications separately.
HttpContext.Current.User.Identity