The iOS app has got the Publish_Action of Facebook. The problem is :
when I use the Test Users to make a share, it can success.
But when I use the real account to make a share, it always failed. I also check the app is authorized in the real account.
I guess there may be any missing setting in facebook's developer site but I failed to find it.
Any idea?
BTW: I do Not use the sdk provided by Facebook. I use a 3-rd party service which integrating lots of sharing service and it doesn't show error log in above situation.
----------Update--------------
For the normal account, the facebook shows
"this does not let the app post to Facebook". But I have get the Publish_action ability.
What's wrong?
Related
Issue
When we try to log in with developer or testers accounts on iOS, we get the error Unsupported Request. Our app was disabled because the tester could not login due to this error.
Scenario
It works on android
We noted that while the app was in review (activated) users successfully logged in using facebook in iOS devices. That makes us believe this is a problem only with developer and testers accounts
We also noted that when we try login with a tester account an openid item is added to the permissions granted. Before this permission is added we manage to login on web, after this token is added we get the same error on web (Unsupported request)
We already filed a bug report to Facebook and we're waiting for a response.
We're using the react-native-fbsdk-next module and this issue has some more info. We're now trying the approach suggested on this comment
Have anybody managed to solve this? It really looks like a Facebook Bug.
Edit (2021-11-24)
The approach mentioned here works partially: works when logging in through Safari but does not work when Safari is not logged in and the app is used.
We're still waiting for Facebook's response
Facebook SDK versions behavior summary
v7.0.1 (react-native-fbsdk: 2.0.0):
Works when using Safari
Does not work when using FB App
v9.0.1 (react-native-fbsdk-next: 4.2.0):
Does not work both through Safari and FB app
v12.1.0 (react-native-fbsdk-next: 6.1.1):
Does not work both through Safari and FB app
Edit (2021-11-25)
We removed Facebook integration for the iOS app because we could not keep going without Facebook login for Android users. The app was reactivated and, after that, we generated a new production build and it's working as it should
We're still waiting for Facebook's response
I am stuck with a situation that I have implemented Branch.io iOS SDK not and generating a link for sharing. But I am facing an issue that if the app wants to share that link on Facebook, in that case, it is giving an error that "There was a problem sharing your link".
Apart from direct sharing from my app if I try the with direct facebook app then facebook blocks my post by giving reason that this link is blocked due to security reasons.
Please help me out.
In a small test project I implemented a Facebook login feature using both iOS' built in Accounts framework and Facebook's official FBSDKLoginKit.
I noticed however that when a user logs in using the native permissions dialog, I get access to more data compared to Facebook's login SDK. I'm able to access birthday and current city:
It's odd, Facebook's documentation states your app should go trough Facebook's Login Review if your app requests access to a user's exact birthday.
Should I be in any way worried to access that information using Apple's Accounts framework? (as it is clearly bypassing something Facebook put in place to protect users). Should this be reported to Apple?
Permission work without review for everyone with a role in the App, else you would not be able to test your App before sending it in for review. More information: https://developers.facebook.com/docs/facebook-login/review
I got following email from apple
1.0.1 Binary Rejected June 16, 2015
17.2 Details We noticed that your app uses Facebook login for authentication purposes but does not include account-based features
offered
I got following attachment
From Apple
17.2 - Apps that require users to share personal information, such as email address and date of birth, in order to function will be rejected
17.2 Details
We noticed that your app uses Facebook login for authentication
purposes but does not include account-based features offered by that
site, which is not allowed on the App Store.
Next Steps
Please modify your app to include account-based features of that
social network or use your own authentication mechanism.
what is the reason behinds it.
I have study the following links
https://www.parse.com/questions/app-rejected-facebook-login-doesnt-complete
App got rejected because only using Facebook as login option?
Apple rejected app 10.6 because Facebook opens Safari to login
Apple review Guidelines says here
5.1.1 Data Collection and Storage
(ii) If your app doesn’t include significant account-based features,
let people use it without a log-in. Apps may not require users to
enter personal information to function, except when directly relevant
to the core functionality of the app or required by law. If your core
app functionality is not related to a specific social network (e.g.
Facebook, WeChat, Weibo, Twitter, etc.), you must provide access
without a login or via another mechanism. Pulling basic profile
information, sharing to the social network, or inviting friends to use
the app are not considered core app functionality.
I've a published app that has an optional login feature without any "account-based features".
I think providing a "continue as guest" option will fix the issue.
This means that your app didn't implement another feature of Facebook anywhere else in your application, if you're asking for explanation. If you make an app that just has Facebook's Log-in API, but nothing else, then your app will be rejected. Find another feature of Facebook (such as sharing or invites) that you can implement somewhere in your application, and try again.
A few possible steps you can take:
Ask App Store review people for clarification. Wait until you didn’t
get a response from them
You can make user registration optional or only prompt for it where
it actually requires
Try it.
Add note, while submitting app,the purpose of using Facebook login in resolution center without uploading new build it will be approve.
If still you face any issue then add some functionality of user login.
For Ex: Use of facebook login is for keeping all records of user in our database and also explain a bit about your app functionality why you use login feature.Hope it will help
Also check
iPhone app rejection 17.2: app requires users sign in with their Facebook accounts
I've been using the Facebook iOS SDK for some app I've been working on -
My app only requires publishing of a photo, and I have no use of any read permissions or basic info.
When logging in using a browser (Simulator) or Fast-App switching (Device) it works fine with just openActiveSessionWithPublishPermissions:#[#"publish_stream"]...
But if I would try the same with an iOS6 device with the Native login, it would show the error describe in the title. Even though I have no need for any read access. This problem only occurs in the native login, and not in the Browser-based or Fast-App switching based logins for some reason.
Any ideas?
I reckon it has something to do with this:
Asking for Read & Write Permissions Separately
You are now required to request read and publish permission separately (and in that order). Most likely, you will request the read permissions for personalization when the app starts and the user first logs in. Later, if appropriate, your app can request publish permissions when it intends to post data to Facebook.
You cannot request read and publish permissions simultaneously using iOS6's Facebook support, and if you attempt to, the SDK will take the user through a less-optimal app-switching or web-based authentication flow.
It seems that they added this in SDK 3.1.