We have a very large solution (some 300+) projects and we are trying to build it via MSBuild on TFS2010.
We can build it via MSBuild on all out development machines, and are in the process of adopting TFS.
The structure of our code is like so:
bin\Client
bin\Server
Framework\ClientFramework.csproj
Modules\Module1\Project1
Modules\Module2\Project2
etc.
Each project has a relative OutputPath which builds the code to the bin Client or Server directory. So for example, Project1.csproj has an OutputPath of "..\..\bin\Client".
We seem to be having a problem that in TFS MSBuild the OutDir is set to a Fixed Path:
C:\Builds\MyProject\Binaries\
So things are getting confusing when resolving the relative OutputPath on top of the OutDir
ClientFramework goes to C:\Builds\MyProject\Binaries\..\bin\Client
Project1 goes to C:\Builds\MyProject\Binaries\..\..\bin\Client
etc.
We also have some Post build events that copy some 3rd Party dll's to the bin folders, these paths cannot be resolved properly either.
I think the solution we are after is to build everything to our existing bin\Client, bin\Server structure and then move the Folders from bin to Binaries.
Any ideas on how to accomplish this or how we should be working, are appreciated, but updating our existing projects might prove problematic, as it all works with VS, developer command line builds and with CC.net.
Since this is first link that pops up with a Google search of "TFS OutDir", I must provide a newer solution. I spent an entire day playing around with OutDir, OutputPath, and overriding them with TeamBuildOutDir. A better solution is to set the MSBuild property GenerateProjectSpecificOutputFolder. It comes with .NET 4.5. More info here: http://blog.codeassassin.com/2012/05/10/override-the-tfs-team-build-outdir-property-net-4-5/
I found the answer on MSDN : http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ff977206.aspx
Related
I'm struggling to get Azure Devops Server 2019 (on prem) to build a complicated project setup of mine.
I have multiple solutions that build various BizTalk apps. Some of these solutions references some of the projects in other solutions/repos. This works fine in Visual Studio (providing everybody names their repos as the default, which they do).
To automate this build, I've created a multi-stage build pipeline that builds each solution in order.
Whilst solution 1 will build successfully, when it comes to solution 2, the msbuild tasks will not reference the outputs for the projects that have been included as a project reference in the solution.
This seems to be because these referenced projects aren't marked for build - because they wouldn't be able to build themselves without them in turn referencing their other projects in the main solutions etc.
Bundling everything into one big super solution file is not feasible.
I'm wanting msbuild to /reference the projects that have already been built in the previous step, as per being included as project references. But msbuild is a complicated beast and I cannot figure out a way of achieving this.
Is what I'm trying to achieve even possible? Can anybody point me in the right direction?
TFS / msbuild, building project references
This is a known issue about project reference in different Repos, but unfortunately it doesn't have a best answer. Because the best solution is always to have a single repository.
Git thinks of files as the content of the whole repository, not as a collection of files. Therefore this is quite hard to do. As workaround, you can consider to use Git Submodules or Git Subtree:
Check the details info from here:
Git and Visual Studio project references
Besides, the solution we are using now is to put the shared code in the NuGet package. Then, you can use the package from any repository, and you don't have to perform any unstable git settings and keep access control as they should be.
Hope this helps.
It seems that msbuild was changed to only reference project references, and that you can revert that to reference all references by setting the property OnlyReferenceAndBuildProjectsEnabledInSolutionConfiguration to true when running msbuild.
Source: https://stackoverflow.com/a/25144169
Have confirmed this works.
I've finally revisited this and done some more experimentation.
The only way, that I can see, to get TFS/msbuild to /reference other projects outputs is to mark them in the solution build configuration to build.
Now if you do this in Visual Studio and try and build a solution that has projects from another solution then the build will fail if the previous solution hasn't been fully built yet (as the other chained dependencies won't have been built). This makes sense.
But with TFS/msbuild, the build will succeed. From what I can tell there is some magic going on that ensures the dependencies across all solutions are somehow resolved. This might be luck, it might be specific behaviour (it's working for me so far).
The problem of course is that it's incompatible with Visual Studio. So I have an extra "Build" definition setup in each Solution file that has all the projects set to build.
This seems the easiest way to manage lots of interrelated solutions without having one big one.
I'm using TFS 2012 to automate a build of a solution which contains multiple windows services and two web applicaitons.
I've used the guide I found here to customize the build process template so that the windows services are put in a folder structure that I like. Specifically:
\dropserver\droproot\MyApp\BuildNumber\
\Service1
\Service2
\Service3
\Service4
This works great, but unfortunately it doesn't work for web applicaitons. If I used the same strategy for those, I just get the contents of /bin for each web app, rather than the full site contents.
MSBuild typically uses the web application targets to handle this, but for some reason, this doesn't work when you customize the build as I have. I no longer get the _PublishedWebSites folder in the build output. (I'm guessing that's because I cleared our the OutDir property of the MSBuild task.)
Has anybody done something like this and gotten it to work with web applications as well?
I think I can help with this, it looks like in the build targets that the published websites folder isn't created if the OutDir is the same as the OutputPath.
So this isn't perfect, but if you add the following into the csproj file in the first property group, you'll get everything deployed into "\bin\deploy\" including the _PublishedWebsites folder
<DeployOnBuild>True</DeployOnBuild>
<OutDir>bin\deploy\</OutDir>
With a bit of customization, this solution ended up working for me:
http://www.edsquared.com/2011/01/31/Customizable+Output+Directories+For+TFS+2010+Build.aspx
Basically, did what that link recommended, but also leveraged a new solution configuration (which I called TeamBuild) rather than conditional property definitions.
I believe the key to making this all work was the passing of the outputDirectory as the TeamBuildOutDir argument to MSBuild. Embedding this variable reference in the OutDir or OutputPath variable was allowed Team Build to build to the correct staging location and then automatically copy files from that location to the drop folder.
I'm going to take this a little futher and get rid of the whole _PublishedWebSites thing, but that will be done entirely in the build workflow.
EDIT: TFS 2013 supports this natively with a simply build configuration option:
Take a look at this thread as this post as well.
Team Build: Publish locally using MSDeploy
Since you need all the files for your web projects, you need to trigger the publishing process, and by tweaking the destination of that process, you can have all of your files copied where you need them.
I think option (2) from his answer will work for you.
I hope that helps.
As I can see in your reference link, it will just compile and package the binaries. It does not deploy the website by the steps mentioned in that.
If you want to get the .html, .css, .js etc. under the _PublishedWebSites folder, you need to do a Web Deployment. This manually we can do by clicking the publish option from right click menu of your VS project and by selecting Publish Method as File System.
But, since you need to automate this in your build and drop it in custom drop folder, you may need to manipulate your MSBuild script by calling a AspNetCompiler task. You can get more information on this at the MSDN link. By specifying the TargetPath while you call this target you can get your Web files deployed at the appropriate custom drop folder.
Happy Scripting.
Have you check this blog, this solved my problem where I wanted customized TeamBuild Ouput Directory.
Customizable O/P with TFS 2013
Customizaable O/P with TFS 2012 and .NET Framework 4.5
I try to update TFS from 2010 to 2012 and have Problems in TFS Build.
In 2010 i use this Solution: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/jimlamb/archive/2010/04/13/customizableoutdir-in-tfs-2010.aspx
But after updating, all projects are in the same (solutions)-folder. I have seen that, there is a new way to seperate projects:
http://blog.codeassassin.com/2012/05/10/override-the-tfs-team-build-outdir-property-net-4-5/
Can anybody tell something about that, or have same problems?
I have spent almost whole day playing with OutDir properties in build process template and *.csproj files with no luck.
The problem I was trying to resolve: I had a solution with multiple Console/Windows applications projects. I needed to have a separate folder for each application instead of one single heap of all DLLs and EXEs in one folder to make it easy to pack *.zip archives of compiled applications.
Finally I found blog post you mentioned - http://blog.codeassassin.com/2012/05/10/override-the-tfs-team-build-outdir-property-net-4-5/
For me it is working like a charm - now I have a separate folder for each project and I don't need to worry about what files do I need to include in resulting *.zip archive.
The default configuration of the Team Build Number Format is:
$(BuildDefinitionName)_$(Date:yyyyMMdd)$(Rev:.r)
It drops all output to \\foo\bar\MyBuildDef_20111031.1 Great stuff so far!
The small problem is that it drops all binaries in that directory without a good indication of the dependencies of the binaries.
How can you modify this property, or otherwise, to have the solution's binaries dropped in their respective project directories?
In the case above, I had expected the MVC website (complete with its bin directory) to be dropped. Instead, we got that PLUS the extra drop of the binaries in the root.
In other words: TFS, please stop dropping all binaries in the root; it looks messy, and it's confusing on which files belong/associated with what.
How can this be achieved with Team Build 2010?
This blog post should help you out: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/willbar/archive/2011/02/05/splitting-team-build-outputs-into-folders.aspx
Essentially, you create a new 'Platform' for each project. Team Build will put each platform in a different directory by default, so you get a different directory for each of your projects.
Build configuration dialog:
Drop folder output:
Unfortunately I have not found a good way to do this yet, though it has been a while since I tried to find a better solution then what I settled on.
Current have solutions for each desktop application, and one with all the websites. I then followed the instructions here to make each solution output into a separate folder.
I've got a solution with Silverlight projects, a couple Web applications and some Windows service and their small Winforms test applications.
When I build it using TFS it puts all binary files in the Binaries folder. It also creates a _PublishedWebsites folder where it puts the web applications ready for deployment.
What I would like is for a few of the projects to have their ouput in a separate directory in the Binaries folder. I want the files that I would normally find in the bin\Release folder to be there.
I looked long and hard and could only find scarce documentation on how to achieve that and only for TFS 2008. There's a good article there link text and another entry for VS 2010 there link text. However, none of these work :-(
It seems that the build ignores the <OutputPath> property. I tried fiddling with the <AfterBuild> property but unfortunately if I use the $(OutDir) property I get ALL the files in the Binaries directory and not only the ones that just got compiled.
At the moment I'm setting up a separate build that only has the projects I'm interested in that get compiled but I would really like to have all the files needed for the release built all at once.
EDIT: I didn't make it clear enough but I'm using the latest version of TFS (TFS 2010 RTM). I set up <OutputPathDir> on the project level as explained in the links that I provided.
Cheers.
In your build definition (.proj) file, check that
<Project>
<PropertyGroup>
<CustomizableOutDir>true</CustomizableOutDir>
</PropertyGroup>
</Project>
Also, you may run into some problems if you're trying to compile what was once a "website" project type (created from File->New->Website->ASP.NET Webiste). They seem to override the output directory every time. We had to convert some of those to class libraries instead.