Firebird TIBQuery insert with returning ... INTO - delphi

Question

I have a firebird 2.x database with Generator and a trigger to generate the key field.
I need to get the returned value from below query.
INSERT INTO XXXX (vdate,description) values ('"+ VDate +"','"+ Description +"') returning vno INTO :ParamVoucherNo
I tried several versions of below code but it dont wrok and I get
Dynamic sql error sql error code = -104
Is it really possible to get the return value in delphi using TIBQuery ?
Query1->SQL->Clear();
Query1->SQL->Add("INSERT INTO XXXX (vodate,description) values ('"+ VDate +"','"+ Description +"') returning vno INTO :ParamVoucherNo");
Query1->Params->ParamByName("ParamVoucherno")->ParamType = ptResult;
Query1->Params->ParamByName("ParamVoucherno")->DataType = ftInteger;
Query1->Params->ParamByName("ParamVoucherno")->Value = "";
Query1->Prepare();
Query1->ExecSQL();
Any suggestions?

Answer 1

From Firebird README.returning:
The INTO part (i.e. the variable list) is allowed in PSQL only (to
assign local variables) and rejected in DSQL.
As IBX uses DSQL, you should exclude INTO part from your query.
INSERT ... RETURNING for DSQL looks the same as a call of a stored procedure, which returns result set. So, you have to use Open instead of ExecSQL.

Answer 2

Your mixing of dynamic SQL with parameters is just confusing.
Do this instead:
Query1->SQL->Clear();
Query1->SQL->Add("INSERT INTO table1 (vodate,description) VALUES"+
"(:VoDate,:Description) RETURNING vno INTO :VoucherNo ");
Query1->Params->ParamByName("VoDate")->Value = VDate;
Query1->Params->ParamByName("description")->Value = Description;
Query1->Prepare();
Query1->ExecSQL();
VoucherNo = Query1->Params->ParamByName("VoucherNo")->AsInteger;

Answer 3

Using Delphi 6 I have the ID returning successfully using an EXECUTE BLOCK statement:
EXECUTE BLOCK
RETURNS ( DeptKey INT )
AS
BEGIN
INSERT INTO DEPARTMENT
( COMPANY_KEY, DEPARTMENT_NAME )
VALUES ( 1, 'TEST1' ) RETURNING DEPARTMENT_KEY INTO :DeptKey;
SUSPEND;
END;
From Delphi you can do the folliowing:
FQuery.SQL.Text := '<Execute Block Statement>';
FQuery.Open();
ANewKey := FQuery.Fields[0].AsInteger;

Answer 4

IBX is not Firebird ready
you can take a look at FIBPLUS who support Firebird features
FIBPlus also supports FB2.0 insert ... into ... returning. Now you
should not bother about getting generator values from the client but
leave them in the trigger. You can also use RDB$DB_KEY. New possible
variants of work with insert returning and RDB$DB_KEY are shown in the
example “FB2InsertReturning”.

Answer 5

Why not get the next value for VoucherNo first, followed by
"INSERT INTO table1 (vno, vodate,description) VALUES (:VoucherNo,:VoDate,:Description)");
?
Your trigger can then either be dispensed with (which is nice), or modified to detect null (or <= zero can be useful too) and only then populate the vno field.
create trigger bi_mytable
active before insert position 1
on mytable
as
begin
if (new.vno is null)
then new.vno = next value for gen_VoucherNos;
end
Client-side you can :
select gen_id(gen_VoucherNos, 1) from rdb$database;
By modifying the trigger in this manner you save yourself a headache later on if/when you want to insert blocks of records

Answer 6

I wonder if that INSERT can be wrapped into EXECUTE BLOCK command.
Would IBX manage EXECUTE BLOCK then?
http://www.firebirdsql.org/refdocs/langrefupd20-execblock.html
http://firebirdsql.su/doku.php?id=execute_block
Hope to try it in both IBX and Unified Interbase in XE2
PS: Even if it does not, I found the library, that tells to work on top of IBX of Delphi XE2 (both x86 and x64) and to add EXECUTE BLOCK support: http://www.loginovprojects.ru/index.php?page=ibxfbutils#eb.

Answer 7

As I know there should be some changes to IBX made. Internally INSERT ... RETURNING should be treated the same way as a selectable procedure with returning parameters.

Answer 8

i know this question was answered a long time ago, but i must write this as clear as possible, for those who need this as i was.
i too, needed the "INSERT..RETURNING" thing.
the Delphi drove me crazy for a long time, until i changed my Data access components.
i even moved from Delphi XE2, to XE5 only because of that...
conclusion : IBX does NOT support RETURNING!
FireDAC is PERFECT for what i need with Firebird.
just move to FireDAC and you'll be able to do everything you need, and with high performance.

Answer 9

If you have a table with this 2 Fields: GRP_NO and GROUPNAME and you want to get the new GRP_NO you have to use RET_ as prefix, see example:
procedure TFormDatenbank.Button1Click(Sender: TObject);
var
q: Uni.TUniQuery;
ID: Integer;
GroupName: String;
begin
GroupName := 'MyGroupName';
q := TUniQuery.Create(nil);
try
q.Connection := Datenmodul.UniConnection;
q.ParamCheck := true; // the default value of ParamCheck is true.
q.SQL.Clear;
q.SQL.Add('SELECT GRP_NO, GROUPNAME FROM GROUPDATA WHERE GROUPNAME = :GROUPNAME');
q.ParamByName('GROUPNAME').AsString := GroupName;
q.Open;
if q.RecordCount > 0 then
ID := q.FieldByName('GRP_NO').AsInteger
else
begin
// there exist no group with this name, so insert this new name
q.SQL.Clear;
q.SQL.Add('INSERT INTO GROUPDATA');
q.SQL.Add('(GROUPNAME)');
q.SQL.Add('VALUES');
q.SQL.Add('(:GROUPNAME)');
q.SQL.Add('RETURNING GRP_NO;');
q.ParamByName('GROUPNAME').AsString := GroupName;
q.Execute;
ID := q.ParamByName('RET_GRP_NO').AsInteger;
end;
finally
q.Free;
end;
end;

Answer 10

From the IBx2 sources, you can do it like this:
//Uses IBSql;
//var Cur: IResults;
IBSQL1.SQL.Text := 'delete from tbl_document where id = 120 returning id;';
IBSQL1.Prepare;
if IBSQL1.Prepared then
begin
Cur := IBSQL1.Statement.Execute(IBTransaction1.TransactionIntf);
WriteLn(Cur.Data[cou].AsString);
Cur.GetTransaction.Commit(True);
end;
IResults interface Code:
IResults = interface
function getCount: integer;
function GetTransaction: ITransaction;
function ByName(Idx: String): ISQLData;
function getSQLData(index: integer): ISQLData;
procedure GetData(index: integer; var IsNull:boolean; var len: short; var data: PChar);
procedure SetRetainInterfaces(aValue: boolean);
property Data[index: integer]: ISQLData read getSQLData; default;
property Count: integer read getCount;
end;
Test enviroment:
Arch Linux X86
Firebird 3
Lazarus 1.9
FPC 3.0.4
Quick note: This works on new Firebird API in the IBX, But I didn't test it in Legacy Firebird API with the IBX.