I'm thinking of two options right now for model-base validation for an ASP.net project I'm starting:
xVal (Steve Sanderson's project) and the Enterprise module that Stephen Walther uses on this page
I don't really know enough to talk about the preferences as I haven't used either of them yet. Any ideas?
Update Using LinqToSql for ORM right now, but am open to changes.
One difference I see in reviewing the two is that Stephen Walther's blog post describes a library which does only validation in the Web server, where as xVal works with jQuery validators to do in-browser validation, as well. This feature, incidentally, is almost completely automatic.
FluentValidation is nice. NHibernate also has built in model validation. Then you need something like Scott Guthrie's technique for binding errors to the UI.
I've been using xVal to and i have integrated it into the IDataErrorInfo interface introduced into MVC RC1. I like it.
Here is a post I wrote which explains a few things.
http://schotime.net/blog/index.php/2009/03/05/validation-with-aspnet-mvc-xval-idataerrorinfo/
Hope this helps.
Shamelessly promote my validation library. Built for jQuery validate & Enterprise Library and work out of the box for just that. That said, functionality and code are simple enough to modify/extend if you want.
You could also check out this new technique on LosTechies http://www.lostechies.com/blogs/hex/archive/2009/06/10/opinionated-input-builders-for-asp-net-mvc-part-5-the-required-input.aspx I like the fact that you inputs are setup globaly which is really DRY. Also you could just skip the client side validation and do an jquery ajax submit form to the server, which performs validation model and business logic all in one place, which is also DRY :) Also it means you will get the product out the door quicker and you can add client side validation later as a bonus or to progressively enhance the forms.
Another vote for xVal. It's real sweet. I like using Buddy Classes and DataAnnotations to do the validation lifting. Outside of making things work with Linq2Sql as you cannot add attributes to your fields, buddy classes give one a bit of flexibility to have multiple models share the same validation info. Comes in real handy for those ModelEditData classes that seem to always become neccessary.
Are you using an ORM? If so, which one are you using? I've had a lot of luck, when using Castle ActiveRecord, simply sticking with their default model-level validation. If you're not using that, though, this is probably not too helpful. :-)
Related
We've been working with ASP.Net MVC2 based web app. We're using DataAnnotations for model validation and we've also implemented some of our own validation attributes. All is working good and the user gets the error summary (if any) after postback. Now, we plan to migrate to MVC3 in near future but meanwhile, we want to make the most out of jQuery & AJAX based validations.
Note that we've not been using any MS libraries for AJAX or validation available with MVC prjects. Our approach is to keep things as simple & clean as possible so we've been using pure jQuery based plugins. We want to enable client-side validation & remote validation using jQuery for which I believe jquery-plugin-validation is one of the best alternatives. It also supports remote validations.
Example:
http://weblogs.asp.net/cibrax/archive/2008/08/01/combining-jquery-validation-with-asp-net-mvc.aspx
Automation:
APPROACH #1: Here it is mentioned that using "MicrosoftMvcJQueryValidation.js"will automate these validations - any comments?
APPROACH #: Here's another approach which seems to provide even more automation using jQuery DataAnnotations - any comments?
If I'm on the right track kindly based on your experience let me know which approach is better.
Further, is it true that this approach will help us migrate the validations easily as we migrate to MVC3.
Example:
http://develoq.net/2011/asp-net-mvc-3-remote-validation-with-jquery/
Any better suggestions are welcome. Thank you.
PS: In any case we'll persist the model level validations.
In MVC3 you are able to rely solely on the jquery.validate.js library for validation (which is included by default), you do not need any ms specific libraries anymore (like MicrosoftMvcJQueryValidation.js or others, you CAN use them however).
Here is a simple blog post explaining how to use it, even going a step further and doing it unobtrusive:
http://geekswithblogs.net/stun/archive/2011/01/28/aspnet-mvc-3-client-side-validation-summary-with-jquery-validation-unobtrusive-javascript.aspx
On a second note:
The ASP.NET MVC 4 Beta was released a couple of days ago with a "go live" license, if you have not started to migrate I would recommend you to consider using MVC4 instead. It runs side by side with MVC 3, so you wont break anything by installing.
You can find the release notes here:
http://www.asp.net/whitepapers/mvc4-release-notes
And download it here:
http://www.asp.net/mvc/mvc4
I strongly suggest that you wait until you migrate to a newer version. Anything you write in regards to validation will have to be rewritten for MVC3/4, so why waste the effort? I'd suggest that you invest your effort into upgrading and utilize the unobtrusive validation in MVC3 (or 4 as ntziolis suggests).
In my APS.NET MVC project I'm using DataAnnotations for validations.
I moved from L2S to NHibernate orm and in fact found that NHibernate has its own validator (NHibernate.Validator)
Does it make sense to move to NHibernate.Validator as well?
For example DataAnnotations has [Required] attribute and NHibernate.Validator [NotEmpty, NotNull, NotNullNotEmpty] and it makes me think what to use.
I've used both in production projects and, if you have the time to make the switch, I would highly reccomend NHibernate.Validator for a couple of reasons:
NHibernate.Validators has a
richer set of validation attributes
(for example, the handful you
mention above)
If implemented
properly, NHibernate.Validators
validations are easier to unit test.
No. 1 wasn't huge for me, and may not be for you, as the set of attributes in DataAnnotations is pretty complete (and you can fall back to RegEx, if need be), but no. 2 was a big deal for me because I wanted to be able to include data validation as a part of my Domain Model unit tests, as opposed to testing those only through UI/Web testing via WatiN or Selenium. Using Validators also allowed me to mix Domain Model rule validation (Property X OR Y must have a value, but both cannot be null) without having to go to another place to do so.
For some basic guidance on using NHibernate Validators, check out this article: http://nhibernate.info/blog/2009/04/02/nhibernate-validator-and-asp-net-mvc.html, and I would also reccomend getting the source for S#arp Architecture, Billy McCafferty's great framework for creating DDD-style ASP.NET MVC applications. In particular, check out his implementation of Validators and the Validator ModelBinder you'll need to create to transfer NHibernate validation errors into MVC ModelErrors. Download the S#arpArchitecture source here: http://github.com/codai/Sharp-Architecture.
The bottom line is this: Using NHibernate.Validators is the more extensible, testable option, but it will take some doing for you to use it properly. DataAnnotations is baked into the framework and easier to get running with, there's no question about that.
Hope that helps.
Its my first time with asp.net MVC 2. Im came from asp.net webforms.
I would like to know how to build a form to add products (for instance) to a database with client and server validation.
Do you have any url useful that explains this?
Thanks in advance.
Best Regards.
Josema.
Try looking through Jon Galloway's MVC Music Store, it's a demo application that might help you. Otherwise the MVC2 articles on Scott Guthrie's Blog will also give you the basics.
This is a very broad question. There are many tutorials out there on how to perform this. For example as far as validation is concerned you might look at DataAnnotations which allow you to annotate your view models with attributes which will be used to perform server side and client side validation (if you enable it). For more advanced scenarios you could also take a look at FluentValidation.
There have been plenty of questions on MVC validation but so far the answer has been pretty much inconclusive.
For my needs in particular, I would like something that generates client validation and server validation from the same description and should allow both model based attributes as well as code based declarations for those using an ORM (e.g. LINQ TO SQL) exclusively.
I have seen some validation packs that have been whipped up to do this but they tend to introduce a lot of dependencies or are reasonably incomplete (e.g. no support for check boxes or no "higher-level" validation).
Do we begin writing our own validation framework or do we wait in hope that the team may actually release something now that they have the structure for validation in place and jQuery on board?
For those out there actually using MVC in the field now what are you using for validation?
Are you aware that validation semantics have been added in preview 5? This article from Scott Gu describes how to use it, and this one details the changes in the beta.
I have not personally used it, and it may not fit all your requirements, but I have no doubt it could be extended to behave like you want.
The best way as of the released MVC 1.0 is to use xVal.
You may also need to look at this post on implementing Linq2SQL with xVal in case that hasn't been resolved/doesn't work.
I'm trying to decide what validation approach to take for a new ASP.NET MVC project. (And wow there are plenty of options!)
The project uses NHibernate, so the first thing I considered was the NHibernate Validator (Because of tight integration with NHibernate). However, as far as I can see there are only a couple of benefits to this tight integration:
1) DB Schemas generated by NHibernate will include details of validation (e.g. column lengths will be set to max value allowed in validation). (This is not really of interest to me though, as I generate schemas manually.)
2) NHibernate will throw an exception if you try to save data that doesn't meet the validation specs. (This seems fairly redundant to me, since the data presumably will already be validated by whatever mechanism you choose before saving anyway)
If there are more benefits to NHibernate Validator please let me know!
Other libraries which I've been reading a little about include:
MS DataAnnotations
Castle Validator
Something else?
I've also been thinking about using xVal to provide client side validation from the same set of rules. However, I hear that ASP.NET MVC v2 will include something similar to xVal (integration with jquery) out of the box? Will this new included functionality render some of the others redundant?
So, I'm basically asking for people's advice on which direction to take here. I don't want to implement a particular scheme, only to have to rip it out when another one becomes the dominant tech.
What has worked for you? Which option do you think has/will have the edge?
Thanks!
I have been using FluentValidation along with jQuery validation plugin and still cannot find a situation they cannot handle.
I like xVal.
You can implement very easily client and server validation with it. Also there is support for column (property) validation on entities that you would like to use.
DataAnnotations implemented by buddy classes and JQuery client validation
Make sure you're using MVC Preview 2
You might be interested in this delegate approach. I was because i didn't like the xVal idea (the solution im currently going with) and the fact that it didn't seem to cater for complex validation cases that crossed multiple properties of the same or even different class structures.